2

My Sukkah uses a common design of a structural pipe rectangular prism surrounded by canvas (looking similar to this one, but built with Speed-Rail® aluminum fittings, not Kee-Klamp® Galvanized Steel fittings). It is constructed on my deck (which is Trex® Composite on a wood frame).

The house is L-shaped, and the deck almost fills the inside of the L. The deck is mostly rectangular, with a bump-out on the northeast corner for the grill, and a bump-out on the southwest corner for the stairs down to the back yard. Currently, the sukkah takes up slightly less than half of the deck space. Here's a rough diagram (not quite to scale, but as close as I could draw it). In this drawing, the house is blue, the deck is orange, the shaded area is the roof eaves overhanging the deck, and the black outline is the position of the sukkah:

existing sukkah on deck

I want to expand the sukkah to fill the entire main area of the deck. Instead of keeping the full box frame, I want to use the walls of the house and the deck structure to support the frame. There are two reasons for this:

  1. The southwestern upright pole is blocking the top of the stairs.
  2. The horizontal poles on the floor right in front of the door are a tripping hazard.

Here is a diagram of what I want to do (see below for description):

new sukkah plan

I plan to make a top frame that can support the schach, and support it using EasyFit connectors, with six upright poles and attachment to the house in five locations:

  • Three red dots indicate location of upright poles attached to deck floor using railing base flanges.
  • Three green dots indicate location of upright poles attached (through Trex surface boards) to wood deck support structure using parallel wall flanges.
  • Five purple dots indicate location of horizontal poles attached to house walls using perpendicular wall flanges.

I need to attach the flanges to the wall through the vinyl siding. I wanted to use these siding mounting blocks (just to provide a flat surface; the screws go from the flange through the block and siding, and into the wall). The problem is that one of the poles needs to connect to the house just above the sliding door. The mounting blocks are 6.625 in. tall, but the space between the top of the door frame and the bottom of the soffit is only 4.5 inches:

soffit to door space

My first thought was to cut off the top and bottom of the mounting block so that it fits in the space, but that won't work because the block is hollow and is designed to allow the center to be broken out, so cutting off the top and bottom means it will warp (and possibly break completely).

My second thought was to eliminate that connection point to the house and move the mounting block down to the next row of siding. Here is a mockup taped to the wall for testing, note that the flange is deliberately not centered on the block, for two reasons:

  1. Moving it higher gives a few more inches of headroom.
  2. It is closer to the stiff edges of the mounting block.

wall mount

The problem with doing this is that I want to have at least two connections to the wall on each side in order to make the structure more rigid.

How can I get around this problem? Is there some way I could make my own mounting block that fits my limited space? Or is there some way I can fill in the inside of the mounting block to strengthen it?

1 Answer 1

1

I would suggest modifying the design slightly to remove the connection above the sliding door and replacing it with a connection at either side:

modified version of OPs drawing showing location of new connections
Note: This was a quick sketch, spacing not to scale. Make it look nice!

At the joints where the green arrows point, connect the pipe with Tee fittings, then put in pipe to the house where the red lines indicate.

If I read your description correctly, that should allow the siding mount blocks to connect to the house, eliminates the concern about running into the door, and more-or-less matches the picture of the block attached with tape - you'd probably want to move the mounting block up one "fold" of siding though, for extra headroom.

Your drawing doesn't indicate scale, but you might be able to get away without having the connection closest to the corner.

I had an additional thought after you'd mentioned that you can't get the wall mount too high due to the soffit. If you need extra headroom, you could make an S-bend to raise the roof, like this:

Sketch showing S-bend with OP's parts and some lines

The black line on the left is your existing wall (wall flange not shown). Add pipe (red pairs of lines) and two 90° elbows to raise the height as much as necessary to provide headroom.

Again, I don't know if you need that much headroom, but it's a possibility.

2
  • If I move the mounting block up one fold of siding, I'll have to trim the top of it to fit under the soffit, which will compromise its structure. The soffit is supported against the siding by a piece of molding which sticks too low down.
    – Moshe Katz
    Oct 14, 2022 at 14:12
  • Gotcha. I thought that's where you were going to put it above the door. Get it in there, wherever it'll fit.
    – FreeMan
    Oct 14, 2022 at 14:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.