We hired electricians to install some recessed lighting in our living room. For complicated reasons, they will not be finishing the job, which only involves installing the dimmer switches and plugging in the new lights, something I'm capable of doing.

They ran two pairs of romex wire (there are two separate sets of lights to be controlled) to a gang box that holds a switch for a light that will no longer be used (I capped the wires and put a plate over it).

In my mind they were planning on using this switch to send power to the lights. However, upon looking in the box, the switch that controls the old light seems to be just completing the hot wire, as there is no neutral wires twisted in there.

Here is a picture of the gangbox where I need to install the two dimmers: enter image description here

Here is a picture of the junction box that held the old light - it was connecting to the wires capped in orange: enter image description here

Does anyone know what might be going on here? Here's my best guess, as a crudely drawn schematic: enter image description here

In my head if I twist together the black/black and white/white wires at the old light's junction box, the black/white pair in the gang box will give me the hot/neutral that I need.

  • Just make sure you remove the switch and cap the wires before connecting anything in the junction box.
    – JACK
    Jul 27, 2019 at 21:51
  • Is there a ground wire (either bare or green) coming into that switch box, either from that cloth-covered NM from the old light circuit or somewhere else? Jul 27, 2019 at 22:04
  • Right idea in your "how it was" drawing, but upside down. The black supply hot nuts to the white switch loop wire, then the black switch loop wire goes to bulb. Jul 27, 2019 at 22:11
  • A white wire connected to a switch (or to a lead going to a switch) is not a neutral. Do not conflate white and neutral. White wires connected to one side of a switch are either always hot or switched hot. All neutrals are white, but not all whites are neutrals. Your lights may be working, but you have wrong understanding of the principles of wiring switches and lights which may get you into trouble. Your diagram is labeled with the switch in the neutral but switches are in the hot side. Jul 28, 2019 at 12:15
  • google.com/…: The white entirely in the box is a neutral. The white between the box and the switch is a hot and it is marked with a piece of black tape. Jul 28, 2019 at 12:17

1 Answer 1


Yes, your black-black strategy in the old junction box sounds right to me.

However, I am concerned about grounds. You need to find out if this junction box is grounded. As you have established, the left cable is only a switch loop, and therefore it must be totally separate from the other switches in that box. The other switches must be supported by other cable(s), and maybe one of these has a ground wire back to the main panel. It is also possible the junction box is independently grounded. If not, then either

  • retrofit a ground back to some grounded point of at least the same conductor diameter as these (don't extend a ground from a 15A circuit to ground a 20A circuit). Or
  • don't connect ground wires from the lamps inside the switch box. Insulate them (don't cut them off). The problem is if a ground fault occurs up in a light, current will have nowhere to go on ground, so it will sit there energized at 120V. We don't want to electrify the cover plate screws on the switch!

You will never be able to bury the old junction box in drywall. You can finish the drywall up to the box and install a blank junction box cover plate, but that cover plate must forever be accessible without tools.

Also do not shorten the now-supply cable any more e.g. by snipping off old wire nuts instead of un-twisting. You don't have any length to spare.

  • thank you very much for the confirmation - everything is wired up and working correctly! I'm going to have to insulate the ground wires, there isn't a ground wire anywhere that's easily accessible.
    – therippa
    Jul 28, 2019 at 2:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.