This is the faucet and shower diverter setup up in one of my bathrooms:
The diverter is not working properly. Even when it's fully in, I get about 25% flow out of the shower head, and the remainder out of the tub spout. And when I pull it out all the way, which should divert all the water to the shower head, I only get about 50% flow from the shower head and the rest keeps coming out of the tub spout. On the plus side, the diverter itself does not leak AFAIK.
I've removed the diverter and this is what it looks like:
I can see through the hole on the side that one of the O-rings is loose and sticking out.
I'm wondering if I can replace the diverter in its entirety or at least the cartridge portion that does the water diverting. The only identifying info I see on anything is Emco on the overflow cover. So it's hard to determine what the replacement part would be.
Am I barking up the wrong tree here? Should I instead replace the tub spout with a generic one that has a diverter built in, and just leave this old diverter in place and non-functional? Or should I order an O-ring kit and try to take this diverter apart and replace the O-rings?
I do see a Moen Waltec diverter at Home Depot that looks a heck of a lot like the business end of the diverter I have:
Thanks.