My single-story ranch house was built in the 1950s, and the roof used to have insulation along the joists. In a fit of new homebuyer fever I switched to a hot roof with closed cell foam insulation all along the rafters. The company removed most of the former insulation, but I still have a foil barrier, exactly like tin foil, stapled to the sides of the joists.

The foil isn't in the greatest of shape, as its soiled with 70 years of wear and tear: mouse leavings in some areas, spattered spray foam in others, and has holes, rips, and tears in various other places from fans, ducts, lights, and trips over the years.

There's even a part over a staircase where it hides a booby trap pitfall almost straight to the basement (!)

What was the purpose of this foil, and is it still doing its job now that the main insulation is in the rafters? Can I remove it to further clean up after those pesky rodents? Is it something that should be replaced and kept in good shape?

1 Answer 1


The purpose of the foil was as a radiate heat barrier and may have also held the original insulation in place. Now that you have insulated with close cell foam I do not see any problem with removing the foil. Like you mentioned you can get rid of the rodent leavings and reduce places where they can live and breed plus places where insects can also live. I would definitely fix the booby trap pitfall it sounds like a big safety concern.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.