32
You're looking at the problem upside down. You are thinking the smart bulbs are causing it. Actually, the Lutron Caseta dimmer is causing it.
The smart bulbs are behaving normally, however their normal behavior is breaking the dimmer.
The dimmer can't deal with four smart bulbs downline of it because (very typically) the dimmer doesn't have a neutral and ...
answered Jul 1 at 14:12
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
19
It sounds like you have light bulbs or fixtures directly controlled by Alexa/Google Home. A better solution, though sometimes a bit more work to install, is a smart switch. With a smart switch, the actual switch is replaced with a device that functions as both a physical switch and as a WiFi/remote/voice-activated/etc. device.
There is actually a bigger ...
answered Aug 25 '20 at 19:30
manassehkatz-Moving 2 Codidact
47.6k7 gold badges67 silver badges143 bronze badges
18
Using the hole(s) in the back is called a "back stab", and, while technically code-legal, they're frowned upon because they can come loose and cause arcing and, if left alone long enough, fires.
The side screws are actually the preferred method and are applicable for either 12 or 14 gauge wire. However, the way you've done it is missing on 2 points:...
10
Someone ran out of white wire
It appears the previous installers ran out of white wire to use for running neutrals, so they grabbed the spool of green wire off the back of the truck to keep the job going. As a result, you'll need to treat the green wires in your switch boxes as neutrals for the purposes of installing your smart switch. This is workable ...
9
"Never" is a bit strong.
This is not a plain "screw terminal" where that would be true. This is a "screw and clamp" and appears to be designed to correctly hold 2 wires, so you are good. That extra bit of brass between the screw-head and the back plate is what makes the difference, along with the two grooves to hold wires in ...
9
Yes, I see several problems.
Wire just stuck under a screw, and not using a proper shepherd's hook with a more than 180 degree bend (i.e. squeezing it together after forming it. Watch a Youtube video on how to put a wire on a screw.
Insulation excessively stripped, leaving bare bits of wire sticking out beyond the back surface of the switch. Not OK. ...
8
Yes, there are electronically controlled gas valves.
A better idea might be to install a "grill timer". It's like a kitchen timer that you twist to set the time, but instead of ringing a bell it stops the gas from flowing.
6
The nut of the problem is the ground wire joining the neutrals in drawing 1. This is a bootlegged attempt to fix a fundamental problem of bringing 5 wires: 2 travelers, always-hot, neutral and ground in a /3+ground cable.
Everything in drawing 1 is bootlegging neutral from ground. This is bad and needs to be fixed Right Now. Not least, nothing in that ...
answered Mar 21 '19 at 20:19
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
6
The remote you use to turn the light on and off is not compatible with LED bulbs. One reason people love LED bulbs is because they use so little power. Unfortunately, some devices in the past used the fact that a regular light bulb can pass some current without glowing. Certain types of switches use a little bit of "parasitic" voltage running through the ...
6
As you know, "green = ground" and "white = neutral". As you probably also know, ground and neutral should only be connected in one place (main panel) and not in individual switches or other devices. So that means one of two things:
Broken Neutral
This is the classic situation. A neutral breaks. Instead of running a new neutral wire or a new cable, someone ...
answered Dec 2 '19 at 1:40
manassehkatz-Moving 2 Codidact
47.6k7 gold badges67 silver badges143 bronze badges
6
Your analysis of the current situation is correct and quite normal. The fact that this type of switch allows two wires to be attached under the switch makes it that much easier to do, as opposed to hacks (MPO) such as one wire under the screw and one in the back-stab.
Yes, it is perfectly fine to have a pigtail to the switch and connect the three wires with ...
5
It's simply a splice. They are using the screw and the backstab to accomplish what they could do with a pigtail. In particular, they are grabbing "always-hot" because this is the first switch. Presumably they are also grabbing neutral.
An ideal 3-way circuit:
What they are doing: (shown translucent)
answered Jul 9 '19 at 17:33
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
5
Mark that green wire white
That green wire behaves at both ends like a neutral. I think it is one. I would get some white tape and spiral wrap it around that green wire, to mark it most of the visible length. Do that at both ends. This is still illegal, but if you don't happen to have a spool of white THHN wire in your kit, you are certainly better off ...
answered Dec 2 '19 at 3:15
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
5
Switches (only) can ground through the mounting screws
No need to run a ground wire to the switch. Presuming the switch has a metal yoke, it will ground via the grounding screws to the metal box (presuming it is grounded).
Is it grounded?
It's difficult to say whether the box is grounded. In 1960 all the boxes were metal, so that alone doesn't tell us ...
answered Jan 21 '20 at 8:59
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
5
Whoever you're listening to on this is spouting technobabble
I'm sorry to say, but you probably should find a better source to read, as whoever's been feeding you information is spouting total nonsense. Whether a device needs a neutral wire or not has nothing to do with any sort of IoT contrivance such as a "smart home hub" and everything to do ...
5
So, given the comments, although electrically this would work, it is unsafe and a code violation. This is because the hot and neutral are to be in the same raceway to have the magnetic field of the hot wire cancel out the magnetic field of the return wire, and thus reduce any induction eddies in any nearby metal components. Such eddies could cause heat ...
5
What you need is a combination of smart switch and smart bulb
You are correct that smart bulbs allow local control of color.
However you still need at-the-switch control of on/off, and that is because of requirements in both electrical and building codes that there be a switch on the usual place(s), and the switch works.
Do use your smart platform of choice ...
answered Aug 25 '20 at 22:38
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
5
Legal colors in conduit wiring:
ALWAYS-HOT: black, brown, red, orange, yellow, pink, blue, or purple
SWITCHED-HOT: black, brown, red, orange, yellow, pink, blue, or purple
There's a convention of black for always and red for switched, but that's purely optional.
Now, these 2 switches have independent control, right? Neither switch is dependent on the other ...
answered Dec 1 '20 at 22:37
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
5
No, you're actually fine on that front here
The C-D conduit meets 300.3(B) despite not having a neutral in it for the same reason old-style switch loops were compliant with that rule: all the power is coming back via the same wiring path it went to the switch on. In other words, current in on the hot = current out on one of the two travelers, which are both ...
5
The large rectangular opening is called "Decora"
There are only 3 popular shapes:
Small slot: the traditional switch, like you have now.
Two ovals: for traditional receptacles (also dual switches)
Large rectangle aka "Decora": which covers your smart switch, AND all Decora switches, AND all Decora receptacles, including all GFCI and ...
answered May 22 at 3:49
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
4
Don't downgrade to a plastic box. Metal boxes are better and what's more, they are often essential in distributing grounding to other boxes. Further in some cities (e.g. Chicago) they are required by Code.
The purpose of a box is to provide grounding and fire protection, and metal boxes do that better than plastic ones in all respects. Plastic boxes ...
answered Apr 5 '19 at 20:16
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
4
This can be done with wireless smart bulbs (or fixtures) and a remote switch in place of your current light switch. I'm going to describe how to do it with the Phillips Hue series, since I'm more familiar with them, but other brands will probably work just as well.
For the lights themselves, if you have not already bought the fixtures, you can get Hue ...
4
That is correct. In the mains power world, we have 3 wires.
EQUIPMENT SAFETY GROUND/EARTH which is not used for anything ever (except during a fault condition, of course)...
HOT which is what humans consider the "source" of power... and
NEUTRAL which is what humans consider the "power return". Obviously, it's AC, which makes "source" vs "return" ...
answered May 20 '19 at 0:52
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
4
Because unlike a normal switch, the wifi switch needs power, so it needs a neutral wire to complete a circuit at the switch between the unswitched hot wire and neutral for that power.
The neutral wire to the switch cannot be a light-gauge wire (at least if you are in an area subject to NEC codes; likely similar elsewhere in the world) because codes are ...
4
I think you hooked up neutral correctly. Stay away from the 3-way switch.
Your assumption that cable 2 comes from the panel may be incorrect. Mechanical switches are direction agnostic, they don't care which is supply-hot and which is switched-hot. Smart switches do. The switch needs supply hot on its (presumably) black. Then, it will power up even ...
answered Dec 4 '18 at 0:47
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
4
You still have to comply with Building Codes
The Building Codes are crystal clear: There must be a physical switch, in a quasi-standard location (you can walk into any room anywhere and your hand knows the 2-3 places to grope for a switch). The switch must be accessible by people who aren't you, and the switch must operate a light that works. That ...
answered Dec 2 '19 at 19:41
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
4
The black wire from the /2 cable needs to be pigtailed to the LINE terminals on both devices
We know, from your testing, that the black wire from the /2 cable is the incoming always-hot wire; this means that the black and red wires from the /3 cable are the outgoing switched-hots for the two sets of lights this box controls. Therefore, we wire the box as ...
4
Yes, this can be installed here
It appears that your installer was smart and not only provided neutral at the switchbox, but provided you with a nicely color-coded set of wires to work with, too. You'll just need a length of black #12 stranded THHN to pigtail the always-hots with, after trimming back and removing the length of always-hot black wire that ...
4
How many wires depends on the nut, and not just the color of the nut. I have red wire nuts that will only take 5 #14 and others that will take 6 #14 (don't recall the #12 numbers off the top of my head and the boxes are not here as I write.) The listed configurations are laid out in detail on the side of the box/container of wirenuts, and you don't get to be ...
4
Yes, smart switches can be quite annoying like that! There are several ways to lick that problem.
Use a block connector that allows a lot of wires.
They make "stab blocks" that are a row of terminals, each with a "back stab". You jab the wire in, and it grabs it. They make these blocks to take up to 8 wires.
Or the MAC Block Connector: ...
answered Jul 16 '20 at 3:01
Harper - Reinstate Monica
194k16 gold badges182 silver badges449 bronze badges
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible