1

I have three rooms in my basement that have all their ceiling light circuits wired up in sequence. They are all single switch circuits and the first two rooms have 4 ceiling lights each and the last (the bathroom) has two circuits in it. One switch controls two ceiling lights and the other controls a ceiling light and small exhaust fan.

All the ceiling lights are 15 watt recessed lights.

I have them all wired up the same as this diagram except move the second switch to a separate box and add two more circuits, plus more lights on each circuit. It's pretty basic wiring. Each switch has three wires going to each box, the first going to the lights, the second coming from the power source, with the third wire continuing to the next circuit. The neutral wires are all connected in each and the grounds are all connected.

enter image description here

This wiring diagram belongs to do-it-yourself-help.com. The original image can be found here: https://www.do-it-yourself-help.com/wiring_switches.html

I noticed two nights ago when my wife went to the bathroom when she turned on the bathroom light, all 4 ceiling lights in the bedroom showed a TINY amount of light and then subsequently dimmed! LED lights take a few seconds to turn off, slowly dimming in the process. It was quite noticeable, but you can only see it in the dark. It's not enough to get around in the dark though.

Is this normal? Do I have a problem with my wiring setup?? Do LEDs behave this way?

Edit - this morning I tested with a voltage sensor, and it does indeed beep for a split second when hold it up to the bedroom light wire while turning on the bathroom light. The same for every other circuit. This indicates a small bit of power goes through the wire. Is it traveling back through the entire neutral wire, even on the other circuits?

Improve this question
2
  • Are these plain vanilla $1 switches? Or are these fancydancy dimmer, sensor, remote, blah blah anything like that?
    – Harper - Reinstate Monica
    Jul 18, 2016 at 0:34
  • @Harper these are plain vanilla, 20A single pole switches. Not cheap quality, but ordinary. The entire circuit is 20A as I have the entire basement light setup on it.
    – hacket
    Jul 18, 2016 at 15:51

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
2

Is this normal?

No, but it is not especially unusual.

Do I have a problem with my wiring setup?

Insufficient information to tell.

Do LEDs behave this way?

It is a common problem with some types of LED "bulb" in certain situations.

LED replacements for incandescent lights are relatively new so a lot of house wiring and accessories that people have already installed are designed to work with incandescent bulbs, not with LED replacement bulbs.

Some older accessories that need to draw a small amount of power at, for example, a switch location that has no neutral (only live and switched live) do so by drawing a tiny current through the light bulbs controlled by the switch, the current is too small to make an incandescent light bulb glow but is enough to make most kinds of LED bulb glow.

The working part of Incandescent bulbs, (the coiled tungsten filament) operate at 120 V AC or 230V AC and draw around 500 mA current when working.

Each of several working parts of a LED bulb (each individual light emitting diode itself) operates at about 2V DC and draws maybe 8 mA from the 120 V side of it's driver circuit.

So it can only take a very small current to make a LED begin to light up.

Since LEDs are low-voltage constant-current DC devices, there has to be some driver circuitry somewhere to make them work with 120V AC. This circuitry is either built into the "bulb" or is a separate box. There are many different designs for the driver circuitry and some of these are more susceptible to producing the sort of effects you report.

I don't know if induced voltages from long runs of wiring next to each other are enough to start to drive a LED, but there are probably many circumstances where this happens unexpectedly - it isn't a certain indication of a wiring fault. Far from it.

I tested with a voltage sensor, and it does indeed beep for a split second when hold it up to the bedroom light wire while turning on the bathroom light.

This does suggest some sort of inductive transient voltage being generated. Are there any fluorescent lights in the bathroom?

To properly diagnose this issue you will probably need more equipment - or hire an electrician.

Improve this answer
1
  • Appreciate the long answer! What exactly is induced voltage? Seems this goes over a circuit even if the circuit isn't closed? I suspected something along the lines of 'LEDs display on lower power' or something similar. I actually tested with my voltage sensor on my kitchen light circuits which are similarly run in sequence, and the same thing happens....a slight beep from one circuit when flipping the others. I suspect this is pretty normal.
    – hacket
    Jul 18, 2016 at 15:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.