1

I have a well in my garden(17m deep, 1m diameter), in it there is a platform on which my water pump for my house sits. Before the water comes out my faucet or shower it travels across some 20 to 30 meters of small diameter pipe. So the water pressure at the end is miserable.

Can I connect another water pump right before(4m of pipe away) my shower, so that this pump would suck water from the first pump, create pressure and deliver comfortable pressure of water to my shower?

Of course, I need some place for the second pump, it would create some noise, but would that be ok or would the first water pump get damaged?

  • I would increase the cutout pressure on the pump pressure switch. this would do more good than a second pump. – Ed Beal Feb 26 '16 at 14:41
  • @EdBeal thank you, I will find the manual for the pump and see what is possible in this direction. Still this would not eliminate the pressure loss due to small pipe, so the result would be still not comparable to a water pump next to the shower, which obviously is no option unless I create a water tank to feed the second pump from – AndyZ Feb 26 '16 at 15:31
2

If the problem is undersized pipe, you need larger pipe, or some other coping mechanism such as a large pressure tank at the house.

Placing a pump on the end of the small pipe will likely cause the second pump to cavitate, which generally damages the pump. Water can only be sucked so hard before it boils, at any temperature.

If you want a pump on the house side, you can do that, but you'd need to provide a large cistern to serve as the water source for that pump, so it's drawing from the stored water in the cistern, not the too-small pipe.

A larger pipe is a much simpler solution to this problem in most cases.

  • Thank you, while I would be able to find some isolated space for the pump, I cannot find place for 1cbm water tank to feed the second pump from it. Also, I cannot change the pipes - that's too expensive compared to my discomfort. So the truth is I have to live with that...sad – AndyZ Feb 26 '16 at 15:28
2

Installing another pump after the primary pump may damage the primary pump, but even if it doesn't it won't solve your problem. The bigger issue is that if the line between the two pumps has any leaks, even microscopic, then you'll be creating a very low pressure in that pipe, which may lead to contamination. You would have to make sure the secondary pump is lower pressure, and this would defeat any possible benefit anyway.

Consider installing a low flow shower head. These are designed for a lower volume of water, and if you can reduce the volume requirements, the apparent pressure will go up. It will provide for a more powerful shower, without having to increase the actual volume or pressure of the existing system.

Beyond that, the only way to get more volume through an existing pipe is to increase the pressure. I don't suggest that you pursue this, though, as you may create or enlarge leaks in the piping you don't want to replace.

As others have indicated, the next step is either replacing the pipe, or adding storage closer to the use.

Keep in mind that even an old high flow shower requires less than 10 gallons of water per ten minutes of showering, and during that time your source would be able to fill the storage, though not as fast as you're using it. So even a tiny 5 gallon pressure tank might give you a full pressure 10 minute shower, using 10 gallons before it goes back to the original pump volume/pressure limitations.

Add in a low flow shower head, and you could use a 5 gallon tank for 40-60 minutes before experiencing reduced pressure.

Further, a pressure tank wouldn't require a secondary pump, and would be cheaper than a secondary pump.

Placing it in the attic isn't difficult - these 5-10 gallon tanks are small, and even when full of water less than the weight of an adult. Adding a box around one with adequate insulation, and removing the insulation below it so it's more exposed to the heat from the living area shouldn't incur excessive costs.

It may be tempting to get a larger tank, but for this one problem it's probably not necessary.

  • thank you, I had a pressure tank in my mind already years ago, even in some earlier answers the pressure tank was mentioned but somehow it didn't come through to me, this must be the single best solution in my case. Sorry folks who mentioned the pressure tank before :) – AndyZ Feb 27 '16 at 7:38
  • I feel bad to make this my answer, as this does not answer my question but it is the best solution for my underlying problem. What do I do? – AndyZ Feb 27 '16 at 7:40
  • @AndyZ I've edited my answer to more directly address your question, hopefully this helps. – Adam Davis Feb 28 '16 at 0:42
2

In theory, there should be no problem installing multiple pumps in series. However, to do so, the pumps must both have the same flow rate. If the pumps are matched, then the head pressure should be additive. In practice, it might be more complex than it sounds.

The common solution to this problem, is to install a pressure tank. While this might seem like an expensive solution, it may actually not be so bad. If you were considering installing multiple small pumps throughout the home, you might find that a single pressure tank isn't far off price wise. If you are considering installing a pump matched to the well pump, you still might find that the pressure tank option is cheaper. This is especially true, if you consider the electrical requirements of the second pump.


Something like the below will theoretically work, but will require three pumps and some new plumbing.

enter image description here

  • I don't think I want a high pressure shower with just a tiny water-volume-output. My initial idea was, that the second pump would suck in water from the first pump, thus increasing the output of the first pump which probably can deliver more water per time unit if the resistance of the pipe gets smaller - e.g. another pump sucks the water at the other end of the small pipe – AndyZ Feb 26 '16 at 17:56
  • If you want to increase the flow, you could install a second pump in parallel with the first. But then the pressure would stay the same, so you'd have more volume but the same pressure. So I guess you'd need a second pump in parallel to increase the flow, then a pump in series with the output of the two parallel pumps to increase the pressure? – Tester101 Feb 26 '16 at 18:12
  • oh, if that is so, that could be a solution. I guess the second pump could be a lot weaker, just to fill the gap between the volume supplied from the first pump and the volume the second pump wants to draw. BUT, my pump that sits in the well can deliver a lot more water when I tap it at the well, so I think the volume the pump is capable to deliver is sufficient - if the second parallel pump would just increase the volume available at the well end of the pipe, would the pump at the shower end really be able to get more water volume? – AndyZ Feb 27 '16 at 7:31
  • @AndyZ If the pumps were in parallel, then yes the volume would increase. However, the head of the pumps would have to be matched, and the inlet of the second pump would have to be connected ahead of the first pump. Which means you'd have to run a pipe all the way back to the well. – Tester101 Feb 27 '16 at 15:15
  • "run a pipe all the way back to the well" that's a game breaker :( Thats's why I wondered how the volume can increase without increasing the pressure on the same pipe and length) – AndyZ Feb 27 '16 at 16:09
1

Yes, it would damage your well pump since it would drain the pump line & cause overheating of the well pump & you'd quickly run out of water until the well pump catches up for just another short burst of water & now air. I don't know your well system's setup of course, but you would need a cistern or much larger cistern in order to successfully run a 2nd pump.

If this inadequacy has been only fairly recent & the pressure has been dropping or stepping down, then it's time for a new well pump as your pump is wearing out. Replacing the pump either way would be your quickest, best & least expensive solution for many years of enjoyment.

  • thank you, no it's not something that has started to appear recently, I run already my third water pump ( 1 x noname, 1 x Wilo, now Makita) in 7 years. The pressure does not drop, it just never appears to my satisfaction. New pipe is no option, then I have to tear down the house and dig up all the pavement. It does not bother me to that extent that I would be willing to do all that work, but it still bothers me – AndyZ Feb 26 '16 at 15:26
  • Well, if you have a basement then there's your new cistern space. Cisterns come in all sizes & shapes. A tall thin box the size & likes of a large bookshelf you should have room for somewhere. – Iggy Feb 26 '16 at 15:56
  • I have no basement, but I have some space in the attic, but there I would have to put some serious insulation around the water tank, because the roof is not insulated. This would mean additional expenses. Thank you, I will think about this option, as the water tank seems to be the only option besides increasing water pressure in the current pump. – AndyZ Feb 26 '16 at 16:19
  • Sorry it must've been a brain fart, I don't know where I got basement from, But yeah, I too think the water tank for a second pump would fix everything. If you have the structure for it, you can go for a number of small interconnected tanks hung from the ceiling & even enclosed in a soffit...like what you may have over your kitchen cabinetry already. Unfortunately, there will be an expense for any solution, even setting up a bunch of large water bottles will have an expense. – Iggy Feb 26 '16 at 16:33
  • Hanging a water storage tank from your ceiling is a bad idea, as water is quite heavy. Unless of course you beef up the structure to handle the additional load. – Tester101 Feb 26 '16 at 16:59
1

Why must it be a pressure tank?

Why not install a larger break tank with the new pump on the output delivering all the pressure you need? I install such systems all the time and all you have to do is ensure the tank is of sufficient capacity to deliver the qty of water per time period.

Bear in mind however that its makeup rate will be quite slow due to the poor from from the well. You can install a float switch which disables the outflow from this tank if the level drops too low. If you dedicate it to just your shower then you can have a pump that flattens you against the wall.

  • "flattens you agains the wall" that's what I expect from a shower :) I will consider an additional tank solution. – AndyZ Feb 26 '16 at 17:48
0

Installing a pressure tank is your only sensible answer. This will give you better control of the entire house pressure and help extend the life of your pump. You are using a Jet pump which is not the best type anyway and as you have said is prone to failing. These pumps will run comfortably for long periods, but constant starting as yours is doing will kill them. With a pressure tank the pump may run for 10-12 minutes to fill it but then won't be used again till the tank is nearly empty. Cost of a 30 -40 gallon tank and pressure switch is very close to cost of an average jet pump

  • Yes, thanks, that's the direction I am looking to now – AndyZ Feb 27 '16 at 16:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.