0

We had stairs installed in August, but the landing oak seems to be splitting at its glued joint and looks unsightly. The fabricators have been out, tried to reinforce from below and filled the joints. Now, two months later, two planks have opened up on the landing! The house was refurbished and of course central heating switched on, but should the landing be opening up like this? Shouldn't it be more rigid? It looks unsightly.

  • 2
    I'm not sure what you want us to help you with. You've got an issue that your contractors need to resolve to your satisfaction. – keshlam Jan 29 '16 at 13:37
  • 1
    Can you show us some pictures? – mbeckish Jan 29 '16 at 14:44
1

Due to climate changes in your house (moisture and heat fluctuations) and the natural tendency for wood to be effected from them, wood will move. The drier and more unsealed the wood is the more it will swell and contract. Also depending on how it was milled and what section of the tree it was cut from will determine how much moisture it can absorb and release.

You are correct in surmising that the landing shouldn't be splitting. Although wood can't be prevented from moving altogether there are steps that can account for and limit this movement. When constructing a project made from wood the planks moisture level should be around 15%. If they are to used indoors with a central heating system an even lower level of 11% should be used. A kiln is used to get this final moisture level.

If the landing was installed using strip (1 1/2-2 inch wide) flooring that was milled with a tongue and groove the tongue should be nailed to the sub floor and into the floor joists if possible. If the boards are wider than 4-6 inches they should be installed in such a way that the fastener keeps them flat but can also allow for slight shifting. This is sometimes accomplished by oval screw holes from underneath.

If the board split is slight epoxy filler/adhesive can be color matched to the wood species to make the patch less noticeable. I would be hesitant to use any other type of filler for a floor patch since the nature of the wood is to move the patch will eventually get pushed loose.

  • Thankyou then epoxy glue it is! They have already filled with sawdust and glue but it's fell out! I suppose we will have to put up with the landing looking like planks of wood instead I thought the landing would look uniform since the 5 inch planks were joined and glued onto a board for stability - my old Oroko stairs didn't split. – Julia Jan 31 '16 at 2:26
  • I would believe that any true 2 part epoxy adhesive that was mixed and applied correctly could become loose after it has fully cured. Once the epoxy is mixed and poured into the gap it will flow into and around the edges of the gap (and will be absorbed slightly into the wood grain). It will cure in 24 hours to a solid dense mass with hardness similar to metal. If the patch has become loose I would guess that it wasn't an adhesive ,but a plastic wood filler. Wood filler has very little bonding strength compared to epoxy. It may have been wood glue which is better than filler but not epoxy. – ojait Jan 31 '16 at 16:04
0

I will agree with ojait and say that a wood filler like dyed opoxy would be your friend here. Unless you want to replace the wood pieces yourself, or if your contractor will not take care to fix the shrinking.

The problem is of course that your drier home during this time of season has shrunk the wood and that really isn't something that the contractor could be accountable for. The only thing that they could have done was buy better quality and drier stock for the project.

It is hard to say if this cracking has made your project less "safe", it may just be visually unappealing at this point.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.