We have a 3-way switch in the garage that I would like to upgrade to a Lutron Maestro 3-way occupancy sensor. I have tried (and failed) to do so twice now... and I'm pretty handy. I'm starting to think I have some sort of "uncommon" 3-way wiring.
Is there such a thing? How would I account for it in the Maestro re-wire?
Configuration:
- Switch 1: Standard 3-way... to become the Lutron Maestro
- Switch 2: Standard 3-way
- Load: Three overhead light fixtures (two of them are 4-foot florescent fixtures, one of them is a dual-bulb incandescent fixture).
Switch 1:
- White traveler (gold screw)
- Black traveler (gold screw)
- Black hot wire (VERIFIED with non-contact voltage tester) (black screw)
- Bare copper ground
Switch 2:
- Red traveler (gold screw)
- White traveler (gold screw)
- Black (black screw)
- Bare copper ground
Here's what I have done so far...
- Tagged the "black screw" wire on both sides
- Removed the old switches
- S1: Lutron with common-->black, white traveler-->blue, black traveler-->black, ground-->ground
- S2: Standard with red traveler-->pole 1, (common + white traveler + yellow jumper)-->pole 2, ground-->ground
- Turned the power one... S1 (Maestro) was dead but S2 was working the lights correctly
- Per instructions, tried switching the travelers on S1 (Maestro) but that resulted in a dead S1 and a dead S2 with the lights stuck off
- For giggles, then tried switching the travelers on S2, but that resulted in dead S1 and a dead S2 with the lights stuck on
I've tried this twice now, thinking maybe I had a bum switch the first time. At this point, I'm convinced there is some funny business going on with the overhead lights that results in a non-standard 3 way... if such a thing even exists.