For electric water heaters that can be obtained with various different options for the size and power draw of their heating elements, will larger elements use more power overall? For example, let's say an electric water heater can be configured with elements that draw 3 kW or 4.5 kW, with the 4.5 kW model delivering a greater first-hour yield. But will the 4.5 kW model use more power in the aggregate? Or will it use around the same overall amount of power as the 3 kW model, but simply deliver its heat faster so as to lower its runtime?

  • 2
    I'll wait for a proper physics person to answer the question, but I believe, if my education served me well...that the amount of energy to heat said quantity of water will be the same regardless of the size of the element. HOWEVER, there may be a relation to size of element and efficiency, which could play a role in things. – DA01 Jul 9 '14 at 22:55
  • Intuition tells me that it should be the same amount of power given a tank with zero losses and the same output temperature; where would the additional power go? But you never know when you leave theory and enter the real world. – iLikeDirt Jul 9 '14 at 23:14

You'll use more power with the larger element, unless you/your family are very strange. You'll use more power because you'll get more hot water before the water heater can't keep up - if you used exactly the same amount/temperature of water, you'd use exactly the same amount of power. Standby losses are pretty minimal for a well-insulated modern hot water heater, and standby losses would be almost the same - except for when they are (very) slightly higher as the tank recovers faster so it's not as cool.

You may need to upgrade wiring if the element size is an increase.

If you want to save money or energy on heating hot water, a heat pump [either separate from the water heater and connected to it (might outlast the water heater), or a "heat pump water heater" (presumably needing expensively thrown out when it dies)] or a desuperheater on your A/C (if you have and use A/C) or a solar thermal hot water system (I seem to recall you are in a hot desert area where this should work well) are all far more effective than fiddling with element size. Naturally they all have capital costs and added complexity.

  • That makes sense. Sounds like it would be a wash since either product would be sufficient to meet our needs. Right now our hot water bill is ridiculously low, like $10 a month in gas. It's hard to see how we can really save much on that. Mostly I want something that will last forever, and I'm looking to move to electric so I can get rid of a roof penetration and facilitate a future solar PV array. – iLikeDirt Jul 10 '14 at 1:57
  • Moving from Gas to electric is going to raise your hot water bill (2-4X depending on the relative local cost of gas and electricity) unless you are moving to a HPWH. Solar hot water is far quicker to pay off than solar PV...heat is much easier to gather than electricity. – Ecnerwal Jul 10 '14 at 2:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.