2

I removed a section of wall not too long ago and did have to rewire some but everything was put back together and has been working for a couple months. The other day it seemed like the breaker popped except there were things on that circuit that were still working. I tested all the outlets with a tester and it says they are hot but when something is plugged in it doesn't work. For example the TV was plugged into one of these outlets and works fine when plugged in to another outlet but not to the original. When plugged into the original outlet the cord is "hot" according to the tester but still the TV doesnt work, what is going on?!!!!

  • 2
    What sort of tester are you using? Can it distinguish hot/live from neutral? can it measure voltage. Could a wire-nut or other joint have loosened and created a high-resistance joint that drops voltage? – RedGrittyBrick Apr 21 '14 at 9:59
  • Ya it looks like a fat pen and the end just turns red when it detects whatever its supposed to detect, obviously I am clueless about electricity its embarrassing... but glad for this site! – Ryan Shdo Apr 21 '14 at 20:07
  • 2
    That sounds like a 'Non Contact Voltage Detector'. It basically detects the oscilating field around the black or red 'hot' wires. A single hot wire can set an NCVD off. Appliances need a hot plus a neutral typically to work. So perhaps the neutral is your problem – Billy C. Apr 16 '18 at 4:19
4

You are not using a "tester". You are using a voltage sensor. Big difference. You are getting a voltage reading but it's not working? This is almost certainly an open neutral on this circuit. A circuit needs both hot and neutral to work. Get yourself a real tester and test from hot to neutral and hot to ground anywhere possible. Find the open neutral and you'll find your problem.

My real advice is to call an electrician. This would be the safest bet.

  • Is this something that most likely damaged whatever was plugged into it? or could it start a fire if left for to long? Thanks for the help and sorry for the ignorance. – Ryan Shdo Apr 21 '14 at 20:09
  • 1
    The box you mentioned is the 1st 1 I'd get at, and I'd turn that circuit off til you get it 100%. Even after that I think I'd find a better place to plug in that space heater if not the microwave too. Even if you have to have another circuit installed for them. Seriously, tripping breakers isn't a routine thing it really shouldn't be happening. – Rand Apr 21 '14 at 21:04
4

Like @Petey said you need a different kind of tester, and one of those plug-in testers with the 3 lights is great for receptacles. Assuming all is properly grounded the tester is capable of indicating an open neutral. I would first confirm that an open neutral condition exist before you go any farther, and then understand that the problem (the bad connection) could actually be at a lighting fixture, switch or any box that this circuit passes through.

A loose neutral connection can even be in the breaker panel, in which case the entire circuit would be malfunctioning. The other possibility, that can throw you, is that the bad connection can be in a box where the receptacle tests good or the light works, but it's not sending the neutral downstream from there. Otherwise you're likely to find the problem in one of the receptacle boxes that isn't working, and my guess would be it's going to be in one of the boxes that was recently installed or worked on.

If you want to get into this, determine which boxes you think you should look in and start with the most upstream one (closest to the circuit breaker) and work (search) downstream. Turn off the breaker for the circuit, and after you take the plate cover or the lighting fixture off probe with your voltage sensor to be sure you're off. After you pull out the device to get a look in the box, probe with your sensor again , especially if there're more wires in the back of the box.

What you're looking for is a wire on a loose screw, a bad stab connection or, more likely, 2 or more wires in a wirenut and one is loose. Examine everything in each box. Tug on the wires, especially wires in wirenuts and stab connections. If you find a bad stab connection, remove the wire from the stab, put a hook on it and put in on an associated screw. If the screw(s) is already occupied (never put more than 1 wire on a screw) either pigtail the wires so that only 1 wire needs to be on the screw or replace the device and use the stab on the new device.

If you're lucky you'll find something loose with no harm done, but you may find some wire damaged due to overheating, especially if you were using the circuit with a high electrical load, anything that heats, cools or has a large motor, in which case the repair will be a little more involved.

Otherwise, I don't know where you're at, but I live in the Phila suburbs and I have been known to work for beer.

1

I agree with Rand and Petey. The plug-in receptacle testers are great for determining what your exact issue is, especially as a novice, but a cheap digital multi-meter ($25) is more useful overall. You can also get just the plug tester for $8 or a combo-pack that includes the voltage detector you already have for $30, all at Lowes. They have a new line of electrical tools that I'm very impressed with. I'm a commercial electrician and I've been replacing my tools when needed with the Southwire brand stuff at Lowes.

I'm in the Seattle area and I'd be willing to help out in-person if you need somebody. I quit drinking because I was a home brewer myself and over-did it, but I'm willing to barter or do a little work for much less than it would cost you to hire a contractor if that's what you're looking for.

Good luck and keep us posted.

1

I just dealt with a similar problem, 3 out of 4 outlets on one circuit showed 120V but would not power anything. The first outlet off the panel worked; I knew the last one couldn't probably affect the others; so I rewired the middle two outlets. Those outlets both used the cheap, older stab connectors; and rather than hot & neutral wire nuts in the outlet boxes, both hots and both neutrals were wired into each outlet.

Turns out the 2nd outlet off the panel had a bad connection somewhere between its two Neutral stabs. So rewiring everything direct to the screws took care of it.

Sounds simple but it took me two days to work out with research & a multimeter. Probably would have been worth the electrician's bill to save the weekend... :-\

protected by Community Dec 10 '18 at 15:38

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.