After having a house cleaner clean my shower, I noticed the handle was inverted. When I asked her about it, she only said that she struggled a bit to turn it off, and that was the position she ultimately found to turn it off.
To fix it I had to remove TWO screws. The set screw on the handle, and then the screw holding the "block" onto the valve stem. The block / stem connection is ridged so it cannot turn, even if forced
How in the world did the house cleaner do this?
The shower water is OFF in both photos.