You want F40T12 tube size
The T-number is the diameter in 1/8'ths of an inch.
- T5 = 5/8" diam.
- T8 = 1" diam. (8/8")
- T12 = 1-1/2" diameter
The 48" long tubes are the most common, and are called F40T12. The "40" is the nominal watts.
Note that T8 tubes will physically fit, but will not work properly with a T12 ballast. If in doubt, pop the ballast cover off and read the labeling on the ballast as to whether it supports F40T12 or F32T8. A bulb/ballast mismatch will perform badly.
And 5000K (kelvin) color temperature
The tubes come in a variety of color temperatures. These decide how "yellow-ish" or "blue-ish" your light looks. You generally want to match all your tubes in the room or premises to the same color temperature so it doesn't look bad.
- 2700K is "hearth and home" traditional incandescent
- 3500K is a warm white by fluorescent standards
- 4100K is normal fluorescent standard
- 5000K is "daylight" fluorescent, which is what you have.
CRI is how nice the stuff looks.
That is Color Rendering Index, a recent phenomenon. Old tubes have pretty bad CRI. All modern tubes are 80-90 CRI and there are even 98 CRI tubes. 100 is perfect light. You can't tell CRI by looking at the tube, but you can sure compare fixtures of 2 different CRIs by looking at the stuff they're lighting up. Good CRI makes things look natural.
90 CRI is readily available in real fluorescent, which is why I'm staying with it rather than going LED (at least for 48" tubes). LED conversions are also an option; some keep the ballast in place, others require you rewire to bypass the ballast. (and others work either way).