My contractor installed a shower niche (commercial one, aluminum or stainless) but tells me that having it holding just by the silicone caulking is enough.

I'm concern that over time, since it doesn't fit so snuggly, it will move and water will seep in. Especially from the top.

It fits nicely against the side of the enclosure, but there is some space allowing it to jiggle around a bit. What would be the correct way to secure it in place and be sure that water doesn't get in the wall?

Is there some stronger adhesive than silicone I could use which would keep water out? The border is about a quater inch thick. The niche sits on the shower pane and sticks out by about a quarter inch too.

enter image description here enter image description here enter image description here

  • (also: I did not mean to create a new [niche] tag. If anyone knows the proper steps to remove it)
    – Jeffrey
    Aug 12, 2022 at 21:03

1 Answer 1


If it's properly siliconed, it will be very secure and very dry.

When you (or a major manufacturer) build a fish tank in the past many decades, there is no frame (sometimes a completely cosmetic, non structural plastic thing that looks like a frame is used to trim up the top and bottom. It does not hold the tank together or the water in.)

The only thing holding a modern (glass) fishtank together, and keeping the water in it, is silicone caulking (for fishtanks, not the mold-and-mildew resistant type, as it kills fish) properly applied to properly cleaned glass and properly cured.

The bottom joint on a fishtank is subject to considerably more water pressure than a niche in your shower is.

Now, if it's not properly applied, sure, it could leak or fall out. But that's not the fault of the material, that's the skill and care of the worker installing it.

  • That's super helpful. Is there any hard rules for properly siliconed ? What I guess was missing, in this case, was pressure, as the niche slid forward curing cure. I'll try again with pressure to hold it tight. I'm wondering if there's any extra care I should take
    – Jeffrey
    Aug 14, 2022 at 16:49
  • 1
    Clean, clean some more and then clean. Also, leave it to cure for a good long while without being disturbed, once it's set properly in place. If, as your pictures imply but your question does not state, it fell out, call the people who installed it and make them put it back right, since presumably you already paid for it to be installed right, and they installed it wrong, instead...
    – Ecnerwal
    Aug 14, 2022 at 17:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.