After some water damage and a ceiling repair I cannot locate the joist to refix the light fitting. It is a circular fluorescent light weighing about 3 and a half pounds.

Is it safe to fix all 3 screws using plastic plasterboard plugs or should I keep making holes until I find the joist so at least 1 screw is in wood?


In the US, a ceiling lighting fixture generally is mounted to an electrical box. The box is usually firmly mounted to a joist or other structural support. ceiling box

Most fixtures have screw holes that align with the standard spacing on the fixture box.

In some cases, where boxes need to be suported between strucutral members, they use metal braces that reach to structural members. The box then attaches to the support bar.
bar hanger

A circular fixture is usually light enough to be supported by the screws into a well mounted ceiling fixture box. If you are replacing the box, a fan type box has extra strength and long screws to support the weight of a fan.
fan box.

They are also available with extra strong braces that fit between framing members.

fan box brace

If the fixture is too large to be supported by the fixture box alone, you can use conventional attachment mechanisms to support the fixture in the ceiling. Screwing into framing members (e.g., joists) is preferred, but toggle bolts or other expanding drywall anchors can be used.
toggleplastic togglemolly

I would avoid plastic anchors because they are the weakest of the options, especially when the weight of the unit pulls perpendicular to the surface rather than parallel to it. See a discussion of anchors here.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.