I was getting ready to tile my basement bathroom and noticed the wall wasn't as flat as I expected. I cut in a hole to take a look and got a nasty surprise. The drywall in my bathroom was glued to the studs rather than screwed. As the house settled over the past 50 years, the paper backing on the drywall tore off at the glued spots leaving a 1-2.5" large gap where it has bowed outwards from compression.

I've been able to use drywall screws to get the upper parts of the drywall properly secured to the studs but as I work my way down the bow out is too significant and the screws just pull through.

I had been thinking of trimming the bottom edge of the drywall to allow for some downward give. It wouldn't be visible due to baseboards but I'm not sure if that would create moisture issues in the long run.

Do I have any options other than tearing the drywall down and redoing it?

  • It's a bathroom floor, it's bound to get wet eventually. I suppose if I ran a bead of silicon along the bottom of the baseboard that should keep it dry.
    – Myles
    Jan 12 at 18:50
  • 1
    It is a bathroom floor before cutting it and making it shorter. Sure, caulk the the bottom of the baseboard trim.
    – Alaska Man
    Jan 12 at 18:53
  • 1
    With you putting in screws that is a lot of the process to replace I would cut out and replace a entire sheet , possibly 1/2 sheet horizontally, I don’t like Sheetrock horizontally but do it on occasion and a slight gap at the bottom / not touching to prevent possible wicking of moisture from the slab this way you have a good surface to work with and zero bow. Most math rooms will only take 1 possibly 2 sheets doing it this way.
    – Ed Beal
    Jan 12 at 19:00
  • @EdBeal Mudding and taping is that one thing that I completely hate. If it comes to that, I'm paying someone else to deal with it.
    – Myles
    Jan 12 at 19:36
  • Step one: figure why you have the largest separation that I've ever heard of. Step two: scream profanities because you now see cause to gut the entire bathroom, if not the entire house.
    – Mazura
    Jan 13 at 1:45

Trimming the bottom will not create moisture issues--nearly every wall in existence has a gap at the bottom. If you're relying on drywall to handle moisture you should hang up your hammer.

Trim away, and if the drywall offends thee by refusing to lie flat, pluck it out. Drywall is cheap and if it's behind tile anyway you can patch in as you see fit. Either cut on studs and patch it in, or cut between studs, float new backing, and screw it all together. Drywall behind tile doesn't necessarily need to be taped. If anything, use fiberglass mesh in your tile mortar.

Also, bathrooms are not boats. They needn't float. I've build and owned hundreds of bathrooms and I've never caulked baseboard. I'd rather have some airflow after a splash situation than a sealed floor that takes forever to dry. You will not keep it from leaking if you flood the room.

  • 1
    I trimmed it and got it flush to the studs. On the worst part after having a couple screws pop through I ended up putting in sets of three screws a few inches apart and turning each a turn at a time. It was slow but it's done and ready for tile.
    – Myles
    Jan 14 at 18:44
  • That's a good strategy. Another is levering off an opposing wall with a long block of wood and a leg.
    – isherwood
    Jan 14 at 19:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.