0

If there was a ground fault causing severe electric shock, and no gfci protection in place, could it ever reach and trip the main breaker, or would it always trip a regular breaker for that circuit first? I'm aware that this wouldn't provide the adequate protection, as the question is more theoretical than anything else. I'm wondering what is the most likely situation in which this could possibly happen for fiction purposes.

13
  • breakers trip due to overcurrent ... a 20 A breaker will always trip before a 200 A breaker, unless the 20 A breaker is faulty – jsotola Dec 30 '20 at 10:49
  • I assume that an electric shock inducing ground fault could induce overcurrent? And you're saying that the most likely way that this could reach the main breaker is if the one on the problem circuit was faulty? – user3043451 Dec 30 '20 at 11:09
  • 2
    A current enough to cause a severe (even fatal) shock can be way below the tripping level of an overcurrent breaker. That's why we have GFCI breakers. – Michael Harvey Dec 30 '20 at 12:42
  • 1
    This kinda belongs on World Building but w/e. How many times have I seen a tripped main breaker? Never in ~30y. The branch CB would have to fail in a state it's unlikely to do so in, feeding wires capable of not burning up while passing over 100 amps (or w/e the main CB is). Or the main CB needs to be a GFI, which is also unlikely because those are ~$1K. – Mazura Dec 30 '20 at 12:59
  • 1
    If there was a ground fault severe enough to trip a main breaker, that would be news to me and a very very major problem. Ground isn't all that good a conductor, decent for safety reasons, but not good enough to trip a 200 amp breaker. And if even a tiny part of that fault was going thru a human, they'd be toast immediately. This is kind of an odd ball question, why did you ask it? – George Anderson Dec 30 '20 at 13:22
2

Probably Not

Note: US-centric. Basic principles apply elsewhere but due to different implementation (e.g., whole-house RCD), this may not be the case in some places around the world.

The key is that ground fault and regular breaker trip are two very different things.

Regular Breaker

The basic premise of a regular circuit breaker, whether a main breaker for the feed into a panel (typically between 60A and 200A), a circuit breaker for in the panel for an individual circuit (typically between 15A and 40A) or a circuit breaker built into a device (e.g., a surge protector - not the GFCI type in a hair dryer) is monitoring the total current flowing through on the hot wire to see if it is over the limit.

A regular breaker will trip in two modes:

  • A lot of current hot to neutral
  • A lot of current hot to ground ("ground wire", not "the earth beneath your feet" - because it is very unlikely to get a lot of current flowing through you to the earth beneath your feet because you are not a great conductor. Well, maybe if you were Leonard Bernstein.)

A regular breaker will not trip if there is a normal amount of current, even if it is enough to kill an elephant. Or a herd of elephants.

The dramatic quick trip (within 2 seconds of a problem) is from a short-circuit or a near-short-circuit. Examples include turning on a breaker after replacing a receptacle or switch with a bare ground wire touching a hot screw, animals chewing through a cable (hot exposed touching either neutral also exposed or ground or metal conduit), certain modes of receptacle, switch or appliance failure, etc. Technically speaking, in these cases it is possible for any breaker in the sequence (e.g., both the branch circuit and the main feed) to trip. Generally speaking, if the branch circuit is small (e.g., 20A) compared to the main feed (e.g., 100A), the branch circuit will trip first, providing protection to the affected circuit without turning everything else off.

Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter - GFCI

A GFCI doesn't look at the total amount of current. It looks at the difference between the hot and neutral or (on a US 240V circuit) between the hot wires. The idea is that all current should go into the hot & neutral wires and no place else. That "else" is "ground". Ground in this instance does not necessarily mean the ground wire. It can mean the earth between your feet. A GFCI does not trip (except if it burns up, but that's not the same) simply because a lot of current flows through it.

A GFCI is primarily for life safety. A small amount of current is enough to kill an elephant - or a person - if the current goes through the heart. One hand on a hot wire, the other hand in a sink full of water, and you've had it. It doesn't take a lot of current (so it doesn't trip the regular breaker) and it doesn't take a lot of time. GFCIs act very fast and with a very low differential in current.

A GFCI will trip in a few modes (using hot/neutral 120V as an example, but similar for 240V):

  • Current leaks from hot to ground wire. Now hot < neutral.
  • Current leaks from neutral to ground wire. Now neutral < hot.
  • A person or animal touches a hot wire - current leaks from hot through person to the physical earth. Now hot < neutral.

The first of these would also cause a regular breaker (circuit or main) to trip. But it will only do so if the total current is large. That happens if there is a real short circuit. Anything short of a real short circuit (where the regular breaker will do the job just fine and the GFCI isn't needed) and the GFCI will catch it and the regular breaker won't.

A GFCI will not trip if all the current in the hot wire matches the neutral wire. Stand totally insulated (thick rubber shoes) and touch one hand to hot and one to neutral and GFCI will not activate. Thanks to the resistance of your body, your regular breaker won't activate. When someone comes over to your spasming body and touches you, then the GFCI will activate, saving them but probably too late for you (do not try this at home!).

The end result is: Regular breakers (circuit or main) catch a different type of problem than GFCI. Both are important for safety. They are complementary, not redundant.

2
  • Thanks for the comprehensive answer. If a regular breaker type of short circuit cannot cause electric shock, then it sounds like the most plausible way to trip everything would be with a whole house rcd? The issue there of course is that the person would then in theory be protected. – user3043451 Dec 30 '20 at 19:23
  • 1
    @user3043451 -- the primary issue is that you'd need to use a big honking MCCB with a LSIG trip unit as your main then -- North American MCB-sized GFPEs (equivalent to IEC-system RCBOs) only go up to 50 or 60A depending on make, while 200A main breakers are readily available and 400A mains are used in some residential situations, with commercial main breakers larger yet – ThreePhaseEel Dec 30 '20 at 23:08
0

Yes, it happens all the time that the main breaker pops before a branch circuit breaker.

Anytime the current goes through 2 protective devices, you have a "race condition" as to which one pops first. In some cases where detection is much faster than the disconnection, you can have several devices trip at once, because they have all detected and started their contactors into motion before any of the contactors have moved enough to actually disconnect flow.

With GFCI/RCD protection for instance, detection is indeed so fast that if several GFCIs feed each other in a string, all will pop.

With overcurrent protection, circuit breakers have 2 speeds. They have "instant trip" which operates magnetically, for extreme overcurrent (5-10 TIMES rating or more). So if you have a 1000A short on a 20A circuit fed by a 100A main breaker, that satisfies the "instant trip" criteria for both of them, and it's race condition for which trips first.

Whereas breakers also have a "thermal trip" intended for mild overloads, that is all about preventing the wires in the walls from getting too hot. Copper has mass, so they take a little time to get warm. Consider a 60A surge on a 20A circuit - that could just be a table saw starting up, but it's not dangerous if it's brief. So in that case, the 20A branch circuit breaker is going to be at 300% load and will trip within some number of seconds. Meanwhile the 100A main breaker won't consider 60A of any concern at all, so it will never trip.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.