I have a 1950's house with gypsum/plaster wallboard as described in this question: Is this plaster over gypsum wallboard?

I have a few cracks in one of the bedroom ceilings and would like to repair them myself if it's not an extreme amount of effort. It has at least one layer of paint on it that's probably as old as the house itself and also a sand texture. The cracks seem to be aligned perpendicular to the rafters in the attic. cracks in corner of house cracks in middle of room

I would like to understand options for how this could be repaired and also the process for doing so.

  1. Do I need to use plaster instead of drywall mud over it since the base is plaster?
  2. Do I need to scrape the sand texture off or can I go right over it?
  3. Should I skim coat the entire ceiling or can I get away with doing it near the cracks and then adding more sand texture to help cover it up?

Edit: I want to share more pictures of the process. I took down the loose areas and drilled some holes for the plaster to lock into for extra adhesion. You might notice that every crack appears under a seam. after peeling loose plaster and drilling holes

  • 1
    Notes: The drill holes seemed entirely unnecessary. Don't waste your time doing that. Also, this stuff sets up very fast. You need it to be kind of thick to work with it for the thicker coats, so make it kind of thick to fill the voids and make it a little thinner for the final coats. Work in very small batches. I used 1 red solo cup of water to about 2 or 3 cups of plaster. That was often too much at once when working on a ceiling. Start small Jun 23, 2020 at 16:28

1 Answer 1


You’re almost certainly going to want gypsum plaster a.k.a. Plaster of Paris

Since you’re fixing a cracking issue, the last thing you want is to introduce something that won’t expand and contract like its neighbors. I’ve gotten away with this kind of repair using drywall mud in a pinch, but temperature or especially humidity swings make it less likely that modern mud compounds will move like the plaster around it and you’ll be back.

Remove any loose or oily material

I like to use a dish scrub brush or whisk broom. Dampen the surface before applying new plaster and watch for spots that don’t absorb uniformly. Remove the coating further on those.

If sections are found peeling away from the wallboard, carefully use a chisel to chip the edges back to solid.

That crack above the drapes will definitely need poked and pried to drop any pieces that have lost adhesion from the wallboard. Hit it with the wire brush, then if it doesn’t crumble back grab a putty knife and poke around. Odds are you’re going to have to make what looks like a bigger mess to actually fix the hidden damage.

The other crack may not be as bad, but it’s hard to tell from lighting. Same treatment.

Feather out like tape and texture

Unless your whole ceiling looks like a spiderweb (in which case congrats you’re probably in for removing and refinishing the whole thing), just feather it in. Be sure to pack all the voids. Sand smooth when done.

Good news is these are good candidates for localized repair. Poke around with your thumb to make sure things haven’t softened, remediate anything that has.

Long lines draw the eye so be extra careful. Sand the paint back a bit (is it lead?) around the areas you’ll be plastering. When you go to sand out the new plaster, use a longer sanding block than you think you can get away with and remember to use an X pattern.

Move the lamps around while putting on final coat and during sanding. Wipe up dust with a damp cloth before deciding spots are too high.

Are you sure you know why your ceiling cracked?

If it cracked due to old settling, great. If you have expansive soils, brace yourself. If you have changed the load characteristics of the building, it’s best if you can wait a few seasons to let it re-settle.

If you changed insulation or HVAC conditions, maybe also wait a few seasons. In-wall moisture changes are of particular interest since if you have gained a moisture problem you’re literally just hiding it by patching the cracks.

  • Some of the cracks have been there for at least 8 years and it seems like a couple have been painted over by previous owners. I'm not positive what caused them, possible settling on that corner of the house? I haven't noticed any moisture problems though Jun 10, 2020 at 23:40
  • @JoePhillips In that case, old settling is most likely and you’re ok to proceed. With them being painted over, you might want to debride / surface prep with a wire brush instead of a toothbrush texture.
    – newcoder
    Jun 10, 2020 at 23:41
  • Added a couple pictures for your viewing pleasure Jun 10, 2020 at 23:54
  • @JoePhillips Outstanding, that helps. Edited to be more specific.
    – newcoder
    Jun 11, 2020 at 1:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.