1. What are some things I should definitely know?
  2. What will be behind my popcorn wall? (The original wall we put the popcorn over?)
  3. Since masks are out of stock because of the Covid19 virus. What should I use for respiratory protection?
  4. I know I must wet it to scrape it. Can I use a spray bottle?
  5. Will the fact that my popcorn walls are painted affect removal?

The wall was put on probably 90s/80s/2000s It’s been through 4 generations of teen girls, my mom asked for it because a guy my grandpa knew was able to put them on. Popcorn walls are uncommon but they unfortunately exist

It was put in 1998/1999 my mom said. They said they put it over just a regular wall. Here's what the walls look like:

enter image description here

  • 2
    What year did you put the popcorn on? If post 80’s it may not be a big deal because there was no asbestos, 70’s or earlier you need to take precautions for asbestos removal. I have never shot a wall with popcorn texture are you sure it’s popcorn? A photo may help. – Ed Beal Apr 2 '20 at 3:35
  • 1
    Yes please a photo. It is very rare that someone decided to put the popcorn spray coating on the wall unless a 70's or 80's installer forgot to drape the walls in plastic when doing the ceiling and accidently swiped a shot against the wall. – Michael Karas Apr 2 '20 at 4:33
  • 1
    Hello, and welcome to Home Improvement. It looks like you now have two separate accounts; you should request that they be merged. And, please take our tour so you'll know how best to contribute here. – Daniel Griscom Apr 2 '20 at 14:38
  • I would consider nailing thin wall board over it. It would be easier, less messy and in the end, smoother. You just need to find the studs. – Steve Wellens Apr 2 '20 at 14:48
  • @SteveWellens - completely disagree there. If you are going that route you would be better off just removing the drywall and installing new. Going over texture is a PITA in many many ways. – DMoore Apr 2 '20 at 18:31

As noted in the comments, you * NEED * to be positive that this isn't 70s vintage, because of the possibility of asbestos. If this was my house, I'd send a sample to a lab.

What's behind the wall depends on the vintage of the house itself. If it's post-50s, it's probably a manufactured board product like drywall. Prior to that, it's apt to be some kind of lath/plaster. Either way, you'll have some sort of a substrate to work from. Don't expect it to be in perfect shape after you've removed the texture -- you'll probably have to skim the whole thing. (This is where the comment about adding a new layer of thin drywall starts to look pretty good, though trim and electrical boxes need to figure into the calculation...)

Mask-wise, you should probably wait until you can procure a mask. This emergency isn't going to last forever in the way that you want your lungs to last forever.

When actually scraping, a spray bottle is probably the best option.

Paint layers on texture will make it much harder to scrape, as the moisture you're applying won't seep in as much. A sharp scraper will help, which usually means either a lot of blades, or the ability to quickly and easily sharpen them yourself throughout the day.


Definitely be careful... the "popcorn" is made from something called vermiculite. It's a mineral (similar to micah) that expands when high heat is applied. There was a mine in Libby, Montana that produced something like 70% of all vermiculite in the US. Problem was, they ran into an asbestos vein. Lucky me, I purchased a home that had an attic chock full of vermiculite. Even luckier, they stuffed the WALLS with it, too. :(

The problem is that it was packaged in bags, and you can't tell which bags had vermiculite. Only lab testing can tell you that. And one sample from one part of an attic (or wall) might test negative for asbestos and another might test positive.

FYI, there was a very large class action lawsuit that was settled, and a trust was established to help homeowners trying to mitigate vermiculite. Basically, you can get up to 50% of $7500 worth of mitigation costs repaid to you. You're only eligible if you have original packaging, receipts, or samples taken from the site which are proven to be from Libby, MT. The lab test for this doesn't test for asbestos (which is expensive), but rather it tests for the presence of other elements (boron if I recall correctly) that are unique to the Libby mine. This website details it all: https://www.zonoliteatticinsulation.com/

The problem with vermiculite arises when it is disturbed. It is very friable, which means it can easily turn into airborne dust. THIS is when it becomes a problem (if it contains asbestos), because it can easily be inhaled into the lungs. This can cause all sorts of respiratory diseases for you later in life. If you start scraping that stuff off, it is absolutely going to get into the air.

When I had my house mitigated, they basically turned the interior into a negative air space so that no dust could escape. The workers wear suits and respirators. They cover everything in plastic, and use water to capture airborne particles. At the end, they use HEPA vaccuums for a final clean up.

All of the remains got placed into bags, and were sent to a Super Fund disposal site. And by disposal site, they really mean storage site. It stays there forever. The best thing is that MY name is attached to those bags, because I own it. Forever.

After the mitigation was done, we still found vermiculite dust everywhere. We purchased some 3M masks that used P100 style pink filters. Bought them from Home Depot.

Here is the mask part (it's a case of 4): https://www.homedepot.com/p/3M-Large-Paint-Project-Respirator-Mask-Case-of-4-6311PA1-A/203632413

Here is the filter part (looks like a case of 5): https://www.homedepot.com/p/3M-P100-Particulate-Filters-2-Pack-Case-of-5-2097PA1-A/202719936

If I recall, they cost $35-40 when we did this. I bought three for my family so we could work in there finishing the clean up. We also bought a really good portable filter that we ran non-stop for a couple weeks. The filter was pretty nasty at the end of the two weeks.

Be careful if you do it yourself!

  • Just a quick point of fact, my understanding is that vermiculite was used for insulation rather than popcorn – Ack Apr 2 '20 at 18:47
  • It was used for both. Although I imagine other things could be used to provide the popcorn effect. – Pete Apr 2 '20 at 18:58
  • Interesting, thank you. Then the popcorn isn't made of asbestos, it's vermiculite which often/usually contains asbestos. I'm always learning – Ack Apr 2 '20 at 19:04
  • I would not say "often/usually". Rather, sometimes. Depends entirely where it was mined. And even if mined in Libby MT, no guarantee that it does or does not contain asbestos. Depends on where those veins of asbestos went. – Pete Apr 3 '20 at 1:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.