Trying to replace an old switch that controls a ceiling fan with light. The original switch had a knob that you would push in to turn the light on or off and use the knob to dim the light.

I purchased a new switch that looks to be a three-way switch but when I installed it the lights would flicker.

Do I need a 3 way or 2 way switch?

I’m thinking the new switch is too high tech as it controls multiple devices, remote, up to 10 items, etc.

On top of that the new device has four screws where my wall receptacle only has two black wires. So maybe I did something wrong when wiring? I connected black with black, but the additional black connected to white.

enter image description here

  • Could you post the model number of the switch? And is that wire in conduit? Jan 5 '20 at 21:02
  • Can you post a photo looking into the top of the switch box, and photos or a model # for the old wall control for that matter? Also, can you open up the fan box and post pictures of its insides? (Maybe it has a clue to the wall control needed inside it) Jan 6 '20 at 2:05

Can't do it

Here's the problem. Your original installation only has the two wires, even though it controls both light and fan. This means the original switch was not a plain switch. It was a complex beast, which multiplexed both fan and light control onto those two wires.

It can be fairly guessed that it's having a conversation either with a smart fan, or with a fan control module sitting up there in the fan box.

As such, you cannot just slap any random switch in there. You need to use a smart switch capable of speaking the lingua franca of whatever's up in the ceiling. Most likely, that is a proprietary device made by the manufacturer of the fan: the information on the old switch will tell the tale.

Or, gut it and start over

Your other option is to completely gut the old control system, and install a new matched-set of fan control switch + control module (and fan too if the requisite smarts is built into the fan).

Since this appears to use the conduit wiring method, you can semi-easily add additional wires into the pipe if necessary; in principle you could even rollback to the old 3+ wire method of controlling fans + lights.

However, the very fact that you're groping in the dark wondering if a 3-way switch is what you need, tells me that you do not yet have the skills to accomplish such a redesign. If you go this route, I'd either bring in help or skill up.

Otherwise just figure out how to get a compatible switch from the same manufacturer.

  • Thanks for the info. The fan was already replaced with a newer model, so I’m thinking of leaving well enough alone and keeping the original switch. Jan 5 '20 at 23:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.