0

I live in Hong Kong and they kind of adopted British electrical standards.

I said "kind of" because they only use Class C (Commercial) MCB; Class B cannot be bought locally. I asked around and they all look at me like I have 2 heads.

The effect of this, based on product specification, is that over-current protection is not as sensitive. This also affects the RCBO protection because they are also rated for Commercial uses (less sensitive; takes more current to trip).

How do I figure out if I can install proper B class residential MCB and RCBO so that it is safer?

4

Type B only affects the magnetic-trip overcurrent portion of the breaker, designed for detecting short circuits. It doesn't affect the RCD part of the RCBO, or the thermal part of the MCB.

Using Type C breakers is fine unless you have such a long run of thin cable that there isn't enough fault current available to trip it at the far end. Hong Kong codes should force using either a smaller breaker or type B breaker in these cases, but usually volt drop will cause people to use a smaller breaker first.

Using a type B makes you more likely to suffer nuisance trips from motors starting, inrush current from switchmode power supplies (turning on a bank of LED lights can be a serious issue for this), and other similar issues.

Unless you have circuits over 50m in length, according to my copy of AS/NZS3000 which is likely similar to your rules, in most cases Type C is fine.

Commercial vs residential doesn't play into it.

I can't comment specifically on Hong Kong code.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.