I need to replace existing gerber toe-push tub popup stopper, because the rubber gasket is worn out. Below are images of the toe-push stopper.

Gerber toe-push tub pop up stopper 1

Click on image for a larger version of the image.

Gerber toe-push tub pop up stopper 2

Click on image for a larger version of the image.

The fitting on the toe-push appears to be either 10-24 or a M5.

Below is image of of the tub drain shoe

Tub Drain Shoe

The depth of the fitting in drain shoe is about 1 1/4 inches

I purchased Danco Replacement tub drain stopper.

Danco drain tub toe push stopper

Click on image for a larger version of the image.

Issue: The fitting the Danco replacement part is 5/16 inches or 3/8 inches. The fitting in the tub drain shoe is less than 5/16 inches. I think the fitting is may be 1/4 inches.

Anyone run into a similar issue and if so can share how the problem was solved.

What are possible alternative fittings or any another options?

Note: I also tried the PF waterworks Fits 3/8 in.and 5/16 in. TubSTRAIN Universal Toe Touch (Tip Toe or Foot Actu.) Hair Catcher Bathtub Drain Stopper in CH appear worked but the gasket was too high thus didn't to the job.

  • My stopper push one side to lock down the other side to release has a replaceable rubber. There was no brand so I took it in to my speciality store and they had the correct seal for ~2.50$. Big box stores have generic parts that don’t always fit but specialty stores may have the part you need on the shelf. 2.50 for a small pice of rubber is a lot but much cheaper than a replacement that did not fit.
    – Ed Beal
    Nov 28, 2019 at 21:22
  • The stopper that you said would have "worked but the gasket was too high" is also for 5/16" or 3/8". So is the issue the thread size or not? Replacements come in various heights... Nov 29, 2019 at 4:44
  • @JimmyFix-it, The fitting of the PF Waterworks stopper worked, but the gasket was too high. I went to homedepot, and could not find a gasket. Danco stopper appear to have a work able gasket but incorrect tread. Nov 29, 2019 at 12:55

2 Answers 2


Take another look at PF waterworks TubSTRAIN Universal Toe Touch (Tip Toe or Foot Actu.) that is referenced in the question.

PF Waterworks Tub Stopper Edited

Per the image the TubStrain product has a #10-20 fitting included.

TubStrain Adapter

On the back of the package the adapter is referenced as “F”

TubStrain Adapter Back

Another issue to take note is the Gasket. If the gasket placed the wrong way the Toe Touch will not work. Make sure the larger diameter of the gasket is pointed toward the drain and the smaller diameter is pointed towards the silver cap. Like an umbrella.

TubStrain Gasket

Also sometimes the gasket doesn't work, because they are smaller than the drain opening. Danco sells the gasket only. Replace the PF waterworks gasket with the Danco Rubber Tub Drain Gasket.

Rubber Tub Drain Gasket

Rubber Tub Drain Gasket in Black


Th PF Waterworks stopper linked in your question has two threaded adapters; one 5/16" thread and one 3/8 thread. Those screw it down to the strainer. Your question specifically mentions those threads as being incompatible, but then goes on to imply that the stopper thread did work, and that the stopper height is the issue. This contradiction makes your problem unclear to readers trying to help.

5/16" and 3/8" are the common strainer/stopper threads. The stoppers also come two different heights: 1 3/4" and 2". Assuming one or the other works for you:

  • determine which thread works for you (5/16" is the smaller thread, 3/8" is the larger thread)
  • go to the plumbing shop, where you should find two available heights for each thread size
  • buy the one with your thread size that is shorter than the one you bought that was "too high"

Example catalog listing of 3/8" x 1 3/4" stopper and the taller 3/8" x 2" stopper:

enter image description here

  • Thank you for responding to the question. You are correct the PF waterworks toe-push drain stopper fittings did work. There were 3 fittings/adapter in the package. Unfortunately I return the stopper. The fitting to old stopper fits and M5 or 10-24 receptacle. Also the depth to the receptacle is about 1 1/4 inches. I have updated the body of the question with the new information. Nov 30, 2019 at 15:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.