I've came cross couple recent bad jobs 1 2 and am dealing with a bad electrical job myself.

Before putting down money and letting the people leave, what resources are available to a consumer to protect themselves (before the fact and after the fact)?

  • 1
    While its'a good question, based on a good premise, it could be argued that it's opinion based.
    – Aleks G
    Commented Nov 5, 2019 at 11:49
  • ... or just too broad.
    – isherwood
    Commented Nov 6, 2019 at 17:39
  • "What resources are available" is too broad for a specific answer. Please revise the question to tell us what type of work is to be done, where, and under what timeline. Commented Dec 30, 2019 at 16:33

3 Answers 3


Comfort level, commonsense and walk away is about all you've got on your side. Yes, services like Home Advisor and Angies List do have some pull, but if the contractor's gone bad then those services can't reason with them.

First off, don't give any down-money and cancel everything with that contractor. Short jobs of a week or 2, by good contractors, will only require payment or start of payments upon completion.

Longer projects of a month or more, with a good contractor, won't require money until demolition is done and a discovery of any obstacles is discussed and planned with the "estimate" being converted to an "Invoice" with an updated Contract...if needed.

Then, the written Contract will spell-out the agreed payment schedule with goals achieved by the contractor before another payment is made or the establishment of a payment plan or financing. A payment schedule should start with no more than 25% and a payment plan should be no more than 10%.

Once the money is fair and square, then you need to possibly force constant communication and take an active interest in the project. Ask how things are going, ask to be shown any problems and ask about sub-contractors or materials that were to have shown up.

If things change and the project is falling behind, communication ceases, work turns sloppy or daily clean-up stops. Then, stop everything and calmly discuss your concerns before the whole crew (if any). Yes, you may have to take off from work to address the changes you're noticing.

If you're met with attitude from someone you thought you had a good relationship with and nothing's getting re-planned nor resolved, then fire them and provide a partial next payment. You must always be prepared to have another contractor take over regardless of project delay.

This is your money and your home or business and he, she or they better shape up back to how it all started or it's time for them to ship out, period. Building Inspectors, the BBB, Lawyers and the contractor's Insurance Company won't and don't act or do any good until there's gross rubber-stamp negligence.

It's always a gamble and the pressures of any work can get to anyone. But, a professional will re-group, slow down and re-trace or apologize and thank you for picking up what they dropped and get things right back on track. You act professional and they'll act professional.

Don't get paranoid and do realize the stage or phase of the project before jumping to the worst your mind can imagine. Observe, take pictures and notes and give it a day or 3 to correct itself. The contractor and crew want to hear your interest in their process and your praise of their work, but whining and complaining will kill their morale.

  • Your contract is with the contractor, not Home Advisor or Angie's List. HA & AL also don't give you the complete picture about the contractor. You need to do your own investigation before signing on the dotted line. For small contracts, I also wouldn't pay anything until material is onsite, then only for the material that the contractor provides receipts. Commented Dec 30, 2019 at 16:53
  • I mostly agree and implied. Thank you for the endorsement.
    – Iggy
    Commented Jan 2, 2020 at 0:28
  1. Write a scope for your project. Do this before you call anyone. Write down what you want to see done and try to come up with a budget and a maximum
  2. Get quotes in writing. Feeling people out is fine, but if you want the job done, a written quote is of tremendous worth.
  3. Referrals are nice, but remember that prior experiences don't guarantee future performance. I've had random hires do stellar work and referred people burn me badly.
  4. Write a final contract up and agree on when payments will be made. Stick to the payment plan and do not fork over money before any metrics are met (i.e. 50% payment when X is done). Never pay full price up front.
  5. Educate yourself and seek second opinions when a job doesn't seem right. Don't just assume the work is being done, or being done correctly. Look at the job during the process and ask reasonable questions. A contractor who cannot answer questions is often a red flag.
  6. Many areas have a contractor board. These vary from state-to-state, but are mandatory in some areas (like California). Contact them to verify credentials if you can.
  • #1 is a often skipped step, myself included. I usually do most work on my house myself, but the few times I have hired someone, I've ended up thinking after "ugh, I really wish you didn't do it like that". It's best to detail how exactly you want it done, with what materials (if you have a preference) and discuss that beforehand to make sure it's viable. Commented Nov 5, 2019 at 14:17
  • I agree with Gabriel. The contractor will most like do whatever that saves him the most effort/time/resources.
    – Nelson
    Commented Nov 5, 2019 at 16:08

Hi I disagree that the homeowner should tell the contractor how the work should be done.It is the contractor's responsibility to know how the job is to be done.The average homeowner would not know how a job is to be done; if a homeowner says don't install rebar in a concrete wall or that movement joints are not necessary for tile should the contractor do it just because the house is theirs? Some homeowners stay home and insist on supervising the contractor. I strongly dislike that. The homeowner can only say how they want the job to look when it is done but they have no say in how that result is reached. Frank

  • I strongly disagree. If the homeowner is hiring and paying someone to do work a certain way, and spells that out in a statement of work before the contract is signed, then that is how the work should be done. Any revisions (e.g. rebar added/omitted, expansion joints not previously specified) may be spelled out in a contract addendum. The homeowner, as the hiring party, has more say than simply how the job looks when it's completed. Commented Dec 30, 2019 at 16:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.