Our house was built in 1964 and I wanted to replace some of the electrical outlets. However, there's something bothering me.

When I turn off the circuit for an outlet, my low range non-contact voltage tester picks something up on the metal outlet box. After some testing, there's a few outlets that have this issue. What's strange is that the beeping on the tester increases in frequency in some situations. For example:

  1. I plug in something in another outlet on another circuit.
  2. I turn on or off or dim lights on another circuit.

I don't have a proper tool to measure the voltage. I'm considering a multi-meter, but I am getting into uncomfortable territory.

An outlet tester indicated that all outlets are wired correctly, except for two that had an open ground. I was able to correct one (the original copper wire broke) but the other one looked fine. I am not sure if this could be related. I will be hiring an electrician, but I'm looking to understand whether or not it is normal for the metal box to have some amount of voltage.

Additional Information: We did identify two receptacles that are "hot/neutral reversed". They were originally unnoticed because they were both upside-down. I am not sure if this could contribute to anything. We'll be hiring an electrician in a few weeks and I'll update the question once I have a response.

  • 1
    Read our QA on replacing receptacles. Outlet testers are for pass/fail testing newly installed work, and are unreliable on the weird problems that come up on old work – Harper - Reinstate Monica Aug 12 '19 at 21:17
  • 1
    Does the tester have its own battery, or is it powered off the line? If you plug a simple resistive load such as an incandescent night light into one of the sockets, does the problem completely go away? – Harper - Reinstate Monica Aug 12 '19 at 21:18
  • Good question-- welcome to Stack Exchange! As @Harper said, the non-contact voltage tester is a pass-fail device, so it tells you there might be a problem. Calling an electrician (as suggested by @Skaperen) is the right way to go. – whiskeychief Aug 13 '19 at 10:48
  • Thanks, all. We'll be hiring an electrician and I'll update the question with what I hear back. It might take a while though. – agriff Aug 13 '19 at 22:01

This very much sounds like a case of what is called Open Neutral. This can be a very serious condition, depending on where it is. Where you plug something in that results in a voltage somewhere else, do plugged in equipment or lights operate properly?

An Open Neutral is when the neutral wire of a circuit is disconnected or not making proper contact. The result is the one or more receptacles are in series with a different group of on or more receptacles and 240 volts is being applied. If the loads are unequal, one load will get a higher voltage (more than 120 volts) than the other. Where more than one load is in a group, shutting of or unplugging one thing can raise the voltage on others in that same group.

This condition requires a licensed electrician to resolve. The only action you should consider, in the mean time, is shutting off the main breaker or main disconnect or pulling the main fuse block.

  • It sounds like a phantom voltage to me, non contact testers quite often show false positives. – Ed Beal Aug 13 '19 at 15:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.