I finished a set of pine 2x12's that will be shelves for a bookshelf using the following process.

  1. Sanded the boards with 80, 120, and 220 grit
  2. Stained the boards with Minwax oil-based Early American using a rub-and-wipe technique. After this, the boards sat for a few days while I worked on other things.
  3. Applied 2 coats of Minwax Clear Gloss oil-based Polyurethane using a wipe-on method. I waited about 2 hours in between coats.

I'm shooting for a mostly natural, satin finish so my plan was to put two light coats of clear gloss on. Let it dry, then use paste wax and steel wool to de-shine the finish if I didn't like how it turned out.

Currently, it's been 72 hours since I applied the final coat of polyurethane. When I touch the wood, I'm seeing oily marks left behind on the surface. At first, I thought this was oil from my hands but I see the same thing when I touch the wood with latex gloves.


  1. What can I do to remove this oily film? At this point I feel that the polyurethane has cured enough that a wipe down with mineral spirits wouldn't hurt anything. Are there any other options I could try?
  2. What is causing this oily film to be left behind? I read this article that suggested it could be problems with the environment or can of poly. I've used this combination of stain and finish in the past very successfully a handful of times in the past so I.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.