I'm sleuthing out a mysterious short in a 3-way circuit and could use some advice. I have an ordinary 15A breaker with a feed to our kitchen pendants, and some outlets in the room. The lights are switched with a 3-way circuit that out of the blue has started to pop the breaker when it is turned on. The circuit carries a load to both outlets and another light. I have been able to determine that when the 3-way switch is turned on it creates a short buzz near one of the outlets and then the breaker trips. I replaced the breaker, but that did not fix the issue. I then isolated the problem down to the pendant lights feed and the 3-way circuit. This appeared out of the blue today, and baffles me.

I pulled and examined both switches and they appear to be fine. The only thing I felt needed to be done was to tighten down the terminal screws, as they were fully extended. The wires are inserted into quick-wire slots. I debated about replacing the switches, but that would be just another easter-egg hunt, and not at all certain they would be at fault. Does anyone have a thought on what to check next? I find it strange that the buzzing noise is not in the 3-way circuit - or at least I don't think so.

  • If it's creating a buzz near an outlet, have you tried replacing the outlet? It's not normal for outlets to buzz. Commented Mar 13, 2019 at 3:53
  • Have you hung anything on the walls or otherwise drilled into the walls recently? Even if done in an adjacent room a wire could have been nicked, causing a short.
    – JPhi1618
    Commented Mar 13, 2019 at 18:12
  • Turns out not to be the outlet that is buzzing as it is live and well. There has not been anything done work wise in this house for a long, long time. I went under the house and had the wife flip the breaker on and tried to listen for where the buzz was coming from, and all I could sense was somewhere above me. Please see my other comment to another poster.
    – DIYGUY
    Commented Mar 13, 2019 at 22:43

1 Answer 1


Grrr hahaha grrr hahaha grrr aaa Solved - and I have a very red face. Turns out that several years ago I replaced a light bulb in one of the pendants. When it did not light up, I determined that the base of the bulb was not making contact with the pin in the seat of the socket. To help it out I put a penny in the socket and presto - things worked (foolish me!). Turns out that the penny moved to one side when a new bulb was installed and gradually made contact with the socket wall - not good!

So, after a breaker swap, two 3-way switches and a lot of bafflement, I have only myself to blame. I'm lucky indeed that was all that happened, lesson learned as things could have turned out much worse. Enjoy the laugh - it's on me!


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.