I’m having some trouble with a light fixture. I have installed a hanging light and it seems that the electrical box in the ceiling is coming out. It has spring clips but they’re not strong enough to hold my new hanging light fixture into place (it’s not crazy heavy, but apparently too heavy for the clips).

light fixture

enter image description here

The circular plate that has the hole in it is metal (I drilled that). The circle hole in the ceiling had a a metal ring that sits inside of it. What is my best choice to secure this into the ceiling?


  • Can you find the nearest ceiling joist(s) to where the lamp is installed? Feb 10, 2019 at 14:49
  • 1
    Some of those "old work" boxes have a spring band across the back top outside. If youu could get the box out of the ceiling, either get a new box with the flip out tangs, or bend the spring band out more, then reinstall.
    – Jeff Cates
    Feb 10, 2019 at 21:18

1 Answer 1


The electrical box in the ceiling should not be able to come through the hole under any circumstances. If this one is, then it's probably a box that was not designed to support a fixture. (You didn't mention what kind of fixture was in this room before, but there are several types of lamps which don't hang directly from a box -- fluorescent fixtures, and "swag"-style lamps of the 1960s and '70s are popular examples).

Unfortunately, your choices are two:

(1) Get an "old work" box that's rated to support a hanging fixture.

An "old work" box is one that installs into a ceiling after the house is built (i.e., now), while a "new work" box is one that is installed while building the house (i.e., before the ceiling is installed).

For the kind of lighting fixture you have, where it pulls down on the box (due to gravity), you have no choice but to have a box that's rated to support a fixture --- typically, this must be reinforced to the ceiling structure. A ceiling box that "clips" to the drywall or plaster ceiling relies on the strength of the ceiling, which means that if the drywall, or plaster, ceiling cracks, due to the weight of the lamp, your lamp will come crashing down. This is a safety hazard, is prohibited by building and electrical codes, and might hurt someone.


(2) Get a different hanging lamp that doesn't hang directly from the outlet box.

There are plenty of fixtures that don't hang directly from the electrical box. Either "strip" lighting fixtures (fluorescent-style), or "swag" style lamps are good alternatives.

  • For swag lamps, you hang them elsewhere, usually from a hook that's screwed into a stud above (also known as a ceiling joist), and then only a cord goes to the electrical box.
    Photo of a swag lamp

  • For a fluorescent or strip lamp, you screw the lamp into the ceiling-joists through mounting holes, so the screws bear the weight and the outlet-box does not. Photo of fluorescent lamp mounted to ceiling

  • Occasionally, you can find a "pendant" light that has a mounting ring which provides screw holes into the ceiling. You'll need to make sure you have something solid in the surrounding area -- a joist very close to the outlet box, for example, which it sounds like you don't have.

photo of a mounting-ring mounted lamp

For each of these choices, the electrical box doesn't have to support any weight, so you'll likely be able to use an "old work" box that just clips to the existing ceiling.

Whichever you choose:

It seems like you should replace the existing box since it isn't secured well enough to the existing ceiling. The box should never come down from the ceiling. A good local hardware store or big-box home improvement store can sell you what you need. If the thought of replacing the box makes you uncomfortable, you should call a professional to complete the install.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.