2

106 year old house - on top of the joists (16" on center) are wide 3/4" thick boards at a 45 degree angle, then 3/5 tongue and groove on top of that. Putting 3" marble hex down and plan to use a 1/2" thick Ditra-Heat uncoupling membrane.

Is that enough support under the tile or do I need to add hardibacker or plywood too? I am trying to minimize height, it's already above the wood floor in the hallway.

Thanks!!

0

if you install over wood, you will eventually have cracked tiles and/or grout. it is not a stable substrate.

If height is an issue, I would take out the tongue and groove flooring, and install the cement board on top on the 3/4" subfloor.

For floor, i use 1/2" cement board.

| improve this answer | |
  • I think this answer was downvoted because it doesn't appear to take the membrane into consideration. That's its purpose. Without that, I'd agree. – isherwood Feb 26 '19 at 20:46
  • sorry i meant 1/2 cement board for floor vs the thiner 1/4 which i use for was. – Quoc Vu Mar 1 '19 at 6:45
  • @isherwood the membrane would helps with expansion/contration but my concern is the floor flexing due to heavy foot traffic. I think it is fine on vertical application. i have seen several instances of the membrane disconnecting from the substrate. when it comes to tiling half of the job is to prepare the substate. – Quoc Vu Mar 1 '19 at 7:02
  • 1
    OP was not specific on how the T&G was installed respectively to the boards below it, thus you could be right and that would be the best case scenario. But I feel in any case appling a heating membrane over wood is asking for problems. Wood is not dimensionally stable and having a heated floor amplifies the temperature swing leading to more acute dimension changes. Also, it is unclear what is the T&G material, but I suppose a house of that age, that would be solid wood and that Ditra-heat will quickly dry out the wood. – Quoc Vu Mar 1 '19 at 17:34
  • 1
    Layers of wood were almost never installed in alignment. In the case of hardwood flooring, the t&g or shiplap sufloor was often installed at a 45 degree bias. – isherwood Mar 1 '19 at 17:36
0

It does not sound like your tongue and groove flooring is a recommended subtrate to attach the DITRA-HEAT membrane based on the data sheet and detailed installation instructions. Hardiebacker, per instructions, needs to be attached to 5/8" exterior plywood. DITRA-HEAT can be attached directly to plywood or OSB so removing the T&G flooring and adding new 1/2" plywood sounds like the way to go. Schluter can ultimately answer detailed questions about your application.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.