0

Okay, so when I started this project I had a buddy telling me what to do and what to buy and it "wasn't going to be a problem." I was told to buy 4/0 aluminum so now I have 235' of 4/0 aluminum in a ditch, and the friend is gone. lol. Anyway, here are my main questions...

1 - I have bought lugs to reduce the 4/0 at both ends to be able to connect to the 100a breaker on one end and the 100a sub box on the other. Is having a large run of wire, reduced on both ends to accomodate lugs going to cause problems?

2- Putting a 100a breaker in the main house panel to power the shop. I don't need another breaker or panel on the ouside of the house do I? I was planning on just running conduit til it gets in the ground and then its direct burial so just dirt the rest of the way.

3- recap - got a 100a breaker in the main panel. 235' of 4/0 wire in the ditch. 100a sub panel in the shop. Got reducing lugs to make the big wire fit. just want to make sure my plan is gonna work before I get after it. any help would be appreciated.

  • 1
    Welcome. Please take the tour, then revise to ask a single clear question in accordance with this network's policy. Post additional questions as you like. – isherwood Dec 20 '18 at 19:17
  • How many spaces does your new subpanel have, and what make and model is your main panel? What type of 4/0 aluminum cable did you buy, anyway? – ThreePhaseEel Dec 21 '18 at 0:37
  • Is digging up the existing cable and replacing it with something else in the cards, by the way? – ThreePhaseEel Dec 21 '18 at 1:24
  • Aluminum URD triplex cable 4/0-4/0-4/0 Monmouth - I haven't buried it yet. Did not want to have to dig it back up so I held off covering it up until I knew I had it right. The only thing that would prevent me from getting something else is my wallet. lol. I don't have the biggest budget in the world. – Todd Stricklin Dec 21 '18 at 1:46
3

TLDR: it's overbuilt, but that's fine. Spend a tiny amount more (or not even) and take advantage of the overbuilding.

Close enough for horseshoes

On #1, reducing the lugs is fine. They make inline lugs, get ones made for 4/0 then knock it down to whatever will fit on the supply breaker in your main panel. It must be at least #1 Al, because that is the minimum wire size for 100A.

This is not reducing fat wire. This is up-sizing correct size wire. Up-sizing is always allowed.

Anyway, there may be another approach here.

On #2, you don't need another shutoff switch on the outside of the house.

Conduit until it's at-depth and then direct burial is fine, provided a) the wire is listed for direct burial and b) the depth is sufficient for direct burial. The depth is 24" of cover overhead, not 24" of trench depth. If the trench isn't deep enough, the day can be saved with conduit: most conduit needs 18” depth, and Rigid/IMC conduit only needs 6" (12" under vehicle routes).

The selection of aluminum wire is dead nuts perfect. 4/0 aluminum was a conservative choice and it isn't wrong. And there's a fourth ground wire in there, right?

The choice of 100A main-breaker subpanel isn't wrong, just cheap, and creates an unncessary problem that could cost more than it saves.

Here's what I don't like

Stock advice is to bump two numerical sizes for every full 120' of length. However this is based on your actual, expected daily current draw, not your breaker rating. As an example, if you expected to draw 40A routinely, that's #6 Al, so you need 2 bumps, giving #2 Al. This bump is not required by Code. At all. Separately from that, Code requires a size based on breaker rating, #1 Al for 100A. Final answer #1 Al.

The usual mistake here is to bump based on breaker rating instead of actual usage, and to treat the bump as inflexible when it's not. I would have preferred your friend have a conversation about your actual expected usage. But this is one of those "nobody ever got fired for buying IBM" deals, it's not like he gave you bad advice. And you are stuck with it, so let's work backwards.

Code will allow 200A on 4/0 Al wire. So as far as Code is concerned, you can breaker this run for a full 200A. "Advice" says 4 bumps for 250', so unbumping, we get #1 Al, so your voltage drop will be trivial until you're pulling more than 100A.


Subpanels don't need main breakers, a main-lug panel will suffice. Subpanels in outbuildings need main shut-off switches. And the cheapest way to get that is to use a main-breaker panel. The breaker size doesn't matter because it is only a shut-off switch.

"Help! I am out of panel spaces!" Is the #1 panel complaint we get around here. It is a very expensive problem. The cheap person who specced the poster's original panel did not ever foresee their desire for hot tub, extra kitchen circuits, GFCI/AFCI requirement preventing use of double-stuff breakers, electric car, nicer table saw, generator/interlock, tankless water heater, Code changes -- whatever, it's always something.

Because of that, we are quick to advise to think BIG when speccing a panel. Big panels come with big main breakers, 100A implies a small-ish panel.

What about the cost difference for a bigger panel? Not that much, and it's a net win, because you don't need to buy 3 of these things since a 200A panel will, obviously, take 4/0 wire directly.

So I strongly recommend to get a 200A subpanel. This neatly solves 3 problems:

  • will allow you to up-breaker this circuit to its true capacity later
  • the 4/0 wire will fit just fine on this breaker without expensive couplers
  • good room for expansion

Now let's flip it around to the main panel. This cable, if not downsized, can be breakered as high as 200A. A larger breaker will solve the "4/0 won't fit on breaker" problem. If your main's main breaker is 200A, you do not need a breaker at all because the main breaker provides the required protection. So if your main panel has thru lugs or a place to lug between main breaker and main panel, you could be all set. Or talk to your electrical supply house about a "lug breaker" that snaps into breaker spaces and provides plain lugs. The only gotcha about thru-lugging is you would not be able to turn off the run to the shed without shutting off the whole house.

  • Thank you so much for all the great info! I am glad I have a bunch of options. One big question tho.... no, there is not a 4th wire. Was told I only needed 3. I don't even have a ground wire coming from the main panel in the house. All of the neutral wires and ground wires are going to the same bars. There is one big wire connecting the bars. In the meter box outside there is a ground wire coming from where the main neutral wire lugs in but that is it. Do I have to run a ground wire all the way back to the house, or can I put a ground in out at the shop? – Todd Stricklin Dec 21 '18 at 0:04
  • 1
    Yes, you really, really do need a ground wire in that trench, we would not advise it if it wasn't both a) a Code requirement and b) essential to make the installation actually safe. It does not need to be 4/0, ask a new question about sizing it. Main panels are different, they receive 3 and locally source their ground, and bonding neutral-ground is done there only. Subpanels must separate them. – Harper - Reinstate Monica Dec 21 '18 at 0:44
0

Wow, your friend had you go a bit big on the wire, but that's not a problem the size is to reduce the voltage drop. 3/0 would have worked.

Reducing the size at the panels will be fine and won't cause a problem.

You won't need another breaker on the house.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.