3

I'm not a flooring guy so I'm asking a question that'll sound silly to pros.

I'm thinking of having 3" solid maple flooring installed. The contractor said 3" flooring needs to be glued AND nailed to the OSB. Even more, all t&g plank joints need to be glued.

I'm not a flooring guy,but I've seen many solid hardwood floors installed on job sites. I've never seen all joints glued or 3" plank glued and nailed to OSB.

Does this sound correct ? Is maple flooring different than oak and hickory flooring that it needs to be glued and nailed ?

I live in colorado where humidity is low and temperature swings are high.

cheers

  • I would think gluing to the osb would cause problems, I have run glue in the groove and toe nail the boards, but I haven't done enough to stand on a position. – Ed Beal Feb 14 '18 at 14:22
  • This strand board is in very good shape, it looks like it just rolled off the production line. When this house was built, it was dry with no rain. The area is considered a high desert. – garyM Feb 17 '18 at 18:17
2

Wood is going to move. It is going to swell and contract with humidity changes in the home. This typically happens during the winter and summer, when the temperature changes outside cause the heat in the home to dry out the air and during the summer the air in the home typically, is more humid. Wood WILL react to this, there is no stopping it.

In my opinion the floor is narrow enough not to warrant gluing down to the OSB, secondly on that, OSB is not the best material to be gluing strip flooring to. Depending how the OSB weathered as subfloor while it was exposed to the elements, the top layer of chips/flakes are barely set in place still, not to rely on for gluing. Beside, you don't need it, But if it is used, it won't cause any problems, it just won't do anything either.

The biggest factor in laying hardwood floors is the humidity that is present in all parts of the process. This is where a moisture meter comes in. Any flooring installer worth his salt has a good one. IMHO, if he doesn't along with what he is prescribing, he would not do my floor.

Since the wood is going to move, and the T&G joints are glued, the flooring will crack elsewhere. Instead of the joints opening and closing the minute amount, when the floor is laid in the proper conditions (this is where the moisture meter comes in) which would be undetectable, with gluing, the wood would crack in irregular places, creating a mess to see on the floor. If the conditions are not right for a floor, I have seen a white oak floor shrink to an 1/8" gap over much of a floor laid where the wood was not acclimated to the house first and laid without consideration for its' moisture content.

| improve this answer | |
  • Bingo on all points, particularly the suitability of OSB as an adhesive substrate. This contractor needs some educatin'. – isherwood Feb 14 '18 at 17:36
  • This sounds reasonable and was also my opinion. Looked at the 10 year climate history, humidity in my area is fairly stable between 35%-45%. However, it is getting drier and other flooring is beginning to shrink. The contractor lets the flooring acclimate for 4-6 weeks. He won't install until 8% on his meter. BTW, I have seen 6" plank flooring installed on OSB using nails with Mapei or Titebond adhesive. (neither is low cost) – garyM Feb 17 '18 at 18:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.