enter image description here

circa 1929, Boston

The kitchen sink connects to cast iron inside the wall. Just below the connection the section of vertical cast iron pipe is rotten and leaking. A couple of feet above it ties into the vent and right below it connects into a hub, part of a ginormous cast iron fitting that has the 4" stack, the outlet to the WC, a, vent for the WC, a Y out to the tub/lav: 6 connections in one fitting. It looks good, doesn't seem to have any of the rot.

Why is it rotten? Does it bode ill for the rest of the system?

I plan on cutting it out from above the kitchen TY to the hub below. It's kind of tight for any type of cutter. Is there a particularly good sawzall blade for this? Any tricks on getting the pipe out of the hub below? What is the best way unpack the fitting. What do I repack it with; can you still even get lead?

  • 1
    Make sure plumbing mafia doesn't know about this!!! Apparently you need to be a "professional" to tinker with plumbing in Massachusetts.
    – Vitaliy
    Feb 23, 2012 at 22:50

3 Answers 3


You're going to have to cut out the pipe, and replace it with PVC drain pipe. You can get rubber connectors (fernco) for the transition.

Here's a youtube how-to: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFaJyIzyiYA

  • 2
    Except that I would use ABS, rather than PVC.
    – Matthew
    Oct 4, 2012 at 16:06
  • Why ABS vs PVC, for us noobs?
    – farinspace
    Jan 7 at 15:15

Why is it rotten? Does it bode ill for the rest of the system?

I would replace as much cast as is easily doable with ABS. I would cut above and below where the K sink drain comes in and replace everything back to the sink with ABS.

Is there a particularly good sawzall blade for this?

Standard metal blade will do - I just cut a 4" myself no problem. (EDIT - I just realized it was steel, not cast iron. Try a regular metal blade, but you may have to use one of the abrasive blades instead. They also have "score and snap" cutters at the home centers - looks like a length of motorcycle chain with a lever on it - never tried those.)

Any tricks on getting the pipe out of the hub below?

I would not do that - cut it (leaving a stub) and use a rubber sleeve connector in both locations. Get the ones that have the metal shell on the outside for support, since you will have a tee-ed in pipe hanging off.

I have (once) cut off a steel pipe entering a cast fitting, and then cut a wedge out of the remaining stub (all the way into the fitting) and hammered the rest of the pipe stub out - but that sucked, and I'm surprised nothing else broke.

  • Can't leave a stub; it is rotten right near the hub.
    – mcktimo
    Feb 24, 2012 at 12:54
  • @mcktimo - ugh, well hopefully you can get it out by hook or by crook, and then a standard threaded ABS fitting will work (use plenty of joint compound aka pipe dope, which is teflon impregnated putty that will seal the threads)
    – dbracey
    Feb 24, 2012 at 16:03

DIY cutting cast iron is pretty easy, but it's a little counter-intuitive. Cast iron is extremely brittle compared to steel. That's important for how you approach it. Cutting it with a sawzall blade is going to be very slow and frustrating. I think the best choice of blade would be along the lines of the diamond-grit "friction" blades, but any sawzall blade is going to be a pain, and any kind of toothed blade is going to wear out so quickly you probably won't even finish a single cut.

On the other hand, the professional tool, a cast-iron "snapper", is simply a chain with a series of wheels embedded in it that look remarkably like giant glass cutter wheels. The cutter pulls the chain tighter and tighter until the iron snaps right at the ring of pressure points. It doesn't get "cut" at all. It breaks at the pressure point.

Along those lines, I've had excellent success doing the following: Use a 4" grinder to score a channel around the perimeter of the pipe where you want it to break. (A "groove" a "ring", whatever language works for you: a circular cut around the perimeter) Then drive a chisel into the gap in such a way that the chisel is acting as a wedge to cause the two pipe sections to split apart and break at the score line.

It produces a pretty clean, not perfect cut, but plenty close enough to use regular fernco fittings to connect to it from there. By far the fastest, least frustrating method I've seen, short of having the "right tool for the job"

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.