I installed a Fluidmaster 400A almost 10 years ago. There is excellent water flow into the overflow pipe, but the tank is taking longer and longer to fill after flushing--now almost 4 minutes. Much water is thus being wasted going down the overflow pipe. Everything else is working perfectly. Do you recommend removing the valve cap assembly to try to flush out debris from the fill valve (I have instructions for that), or should I just buy a new 400A and replace the old unit? (I always have problems with leaks when I do replacements.)


Cleaning out the valve should help. On the other hand, a new 400A fill valve is about $7.50 and it will take you under 5 minutes to replace your existing one (water off, slide the retainer ring up, pull the old valve, throw it away, put the new valve down at the same height, click the retainer ring back down, re-attach tube to overflow, water on).

I'm pretty sure any pro would just replace the valve to save time.

| improve this answer | |

Yes pull the cap and flush the valve. I have done this many times. Turn the water off flush to dump the tank and bleed the line. Remove the cap. Place a cup or bowl over the top and while holding the cup in place turn the water on. You might get a large amount of fine sand, rust pebbles, even pieces of pipe sealant all things I have found in the past when doing this. Turn water off replace cap, possibly clean debris out of tank. Turn water back on and see if that cleared the blockage. There have been times where I got loads of stuff out and it did not help but most of the time it has fixed the problem. With low flow and leaking.

| improve this answer | |
  • If you have the cap off, you might put in a new seal. The seals are not cheap, but replacing one is a lot easier than replacing the whole valve assembly. – Jim Stewart Aug 31 '17 at 0:21
  • 1
    I pulled the cap and flushed the valve. Water flow was strong, as I expected because of the excellent normal flow from the refill tube into the overflow pipe. Put the cap back on. Took 5 min. for the tank to fill. Next I swapped the cap with one from another toilet that is working perfectly. Took about 4 min. for the tank to fill. Looks like I'll have to replace the whole unit. Just out of curiosity, where do you think the valve is clogged, given these symptoms? – Richard Hevener Aug 31 '17 at 18:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.