1

I bought my first home (townhouse) I want to install a smart thermostat I have only one HVAC and the thermostat is located in the main floor. I have noticed that upstairs is hotter than the main floor, ecobee 4 has sensors you can buy for each room. If I only have one furnace is this an overkill since the HVAC will blow air to the whole house?

  • VTC as opinion-based. However, just because you only have one HVAC unit does not mean it heats / cools all rooms the same. The main benefit (IMO) of the ecobee in particular is the ability to set the temperature based on the room(s) where you are, and the sensors allow you to do that. With your upstairs being hotter, the sensors would allow you to run the AC more at night, for instance, so that your upstairs is more comfortable (though your downstairs might become a bit too cold), or run the heat more so the downstairs is more comfortable. – mmathis Jun 5 '17 at 20:59
2

Zone system

A true zone system allows different areas of the house to be isolated, by closing off certain areas using dampers, or just having completely isolated air handlers.

This allows fairly accurate control of the temperature each zone, allowing a specific (and if desired, different) temperature to be maintained in each.

Multiple sensors

The Ecobee is more of a "multiple thermostat" or "zoned sensors" system (not sure if there's a more proper name). The limitation is there is no isolation in air handling, so multiple zones cannot be controlled independently.

However, there are two distinct advantages over the typical "single thermostat" setup:

1) The house can be maintained at a temperature based on averages of all sensors

As an example, let's say right now the upstairs is 26 while the main floor is 21, and your target is 21.

By averaging everything, it'll keep the house slightly cooler and set the upstairs to 23 (a bit above target) while the downstairs is 19 (at bit below target).

2) Which sensors you're using can be scheduled

This means during the day, you can give priority to the main floor living spaces, while at night you give priority to the upstairs.

The downside is during the day the upstairs floor is uncomfortably hot, and during the night the main floor is colder than desired, but the areas where people mainly are stays at a nice temperature.


Aside, I have an Ecobee3 and this works extremely well for me. I also use the "ensure fan runs for at least x min/hour" feature which recirculates air and (I think) keeps everything more even.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.