1

Background

Over the past week I've ripped up the old decking and railings on our 12x15 deck, and installed new railings and all but the last two boards. Noticing that there was no ledger flashing, I pulled back the siding, and then noticed termite and rot damage behind the ledger board. I went to the basement, and cut through the drywall ceiling to inspect, and then verified that we have about a four foot section of rim joist affected. I saw no termites so presume this must be old damage. The four or so lag bolts through the ledger to this rim joist obviously weren't providing any support.

Behind the ledger board is a piece of old aluminum siding, so the deck was done when the old siding was in place and they didn't bother cutting out the siding, and didn't bother putting any flashing in place. Then later when the siding was replaced with vinyl, they didnt' bother putting flashing over the ledger either.

Detail

The house has 2x10 floor joists, 16" on center. At the top of the wall giong from inside the house to outside, there's 1/2" drywall, 2x4 top plate, 1" gap, 2x6 sill plate, 2x10 rim joist, small piece of aluminum siding with nailing flange, then 2x10 ledger board. The gap and sill plate are over concrete block, and the rim joist appears to be above the brick veneer.

existing rim joist detail

Option 1

Convert to freestanding deck. This would entail adding two to four posts along with footers. There's a concrete pad under the deck so I believe I'd have to cut through that, I don't think I can bear on it. Quite a bit of work, couple hundred dollars in materials, and ugly and intrusive posts in the way.

Option 2

Put temporary bracing under deck joists, jack up deck onto it, cut deck joists about a foot out, remove ledger board and rim joist, install new ledger board and rim joist, sister deck joists to new ledger board. Not too expensive, fair amount of work.

Option 3

Double up 2x10 blocking to go between each joist, such that one half is positively on the sill plate, and the other is in place of the old rim joist and directly against the ledger board. Use structural screws to fasten ledger board to blocking, and use steel angles to join blocking to joists and sill plate.

proposed rim joist detail

This would be the easiest option, a little expensive due to the angles and fasteners required, and has the most uncertainties, to the point I think I'd want an engineers opinion.

Question

I like option 3, but would like to do some calculations to ensure I'm providing sufficient support. What resources would I need to reference to calculate the forces involved? I've found tables giving the allowable loads for fasteners and framing angles, but I understand there's somewhat of a cantilever effect with the ledger board being spaced 1.5" away from the vertical load bearing surface of the sill plate, and I'm not sure how to account for that fully.

  • 2
    You've provided plenty of detail, but you haven't asked a clear question. You've come to the wrong place if you want an engineer's opinion, as most of us aren't and we'd want a site visit anyway. Also, "opinion" questions are generally off-topic. Please edit to ask something more specific. – isherwood May 8 '17 at 14:04
  • @isherwood, I see your point. I've added a question at the end that addresses my desire in the end to go with the last option if it works. I would like to go through this excerise even if I ultimately do get an engineer's opinion. – joshdoe May 8 '17 at 14:55
  • #3 looks sound to me, but the critical connection will be the blocking to the joists, where some twisting force will probably exist. If you do that effectively (I'd use construction adhesive in addition to your mechanical fasteners), the system should work just fine. I have no calculations to offer, just lots of experience. – isherwood May 8 '17 at 15:11
  • The question seems to indicate that the deck is a story up from ground level. In many areas, that would be required to be freestanding rather than relying on the house connection for support. The posts don't need to be ugly, they can be covered or finished to blend in. If their position would block the view through windows, you can locate the posts so they don't. If they are next to the house, they won't block much view outside. It isn't that big a deal to cut out holes in an existing slab for footers, and everything can be returned to the original appearance around the posts. – fixer1234 May 8 '17 at 22:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.