3

I have been checking my house circuits and came across a run that is made up of 14/3 on 2 separate fuses, which branch off in the attic to two runs through the house. I don't like the idea of the neutral being shared throughout. I drew a picture of what I found and am wondering if the solution I have come up with looks ok to some of you professionals. And Hello from Nova Scotia. I thank you for any input in advance. My wiring.

  • Are they truly fuses, and not circuit breakers? – Tester101 Jan 16 '17 at 15:10
  • Definitely fuses – RWHobbs Jan 16 '17 at 20:28
5

As long as the circuits are on different phases there's a decent chance this is safe as is, but it's a bad idea to wire this way in a home and a good idea to fix it. You can't be sure of what's behind the walls but your solution might completely repair the situation and will be no worse. Better to attach your new run to an outlet than a light. If you use a light be aware that some lighting circuits are powered from the ceiling box, others are powered from the switch box. Make sure to connect to an unswitched point in the circuit.

The style of wiring you found is common in large commercial installations. It is simpler and cheaper to reduce the number of neutrals running around the place by 1/2 or 2/3. If using conduit and individual conductors it saves pulling extra neutrals for nothing. But the key is that it has to be designed and maintained properly. All the circuits sharing a neutral have to be on different phases. If an installation is designed so that ALL its circuits are run this way, and if professional electricians do all the maintenance over the years and decades, this will work fine because everyone knows what's going on. But in a home, those are terrible assumptions. If one of the breakers on a circuit like this fails, and is replaced, and the new one is on the wrong phase (because the homeowner doesn't know it was done this way or even a pro doesn't realize) then the neutral will be overloaded and the breakers won't protect it. Also, if a homeowner turns off one circuit to do maintenance he won't realize that there are live wires in the junction box he's servicing or that there could be a dangerous voltage across a broken neutral during servicing.

  • Yeah, right now his situation isn't even to Code because there's no common disconnecting means for the MWBC. – ThreePhaseEel Jan 16 '17 at 15:10
  • 2
    Since all his outlets are downstream of the split, he's in a situation where the disconnecting means and pigtailing is fairly irrelevant to safety. There's only one box where pigtailing neutral is an issue, and that's rather obviously a MWBC since a 14/3 splits into two 14/2s. – Harper - Reinstate Monica Jan 16 '17 at 17:27
  • Thank you guys for the input. I mess around with my own wiring a lot, but only have seen the 3 wire setup for 240 volt or my 2 way switches. I feel a bit safer now, but would still like to eliminate it. Just want to make sure the way I was going to do it seemed OK. And I can't figure out what the saving was on the wire as it is no more than a 20' run of 3 wire from the panel up to the box. Thanks again. – RWHobbs Jan 16 '17 at 20:04
5

What you're describing is a multi-wire branch circuit. It's totally fine - I don't agree with the fear of them. Even better, your neutral splits for good prior to the first receptacle or lamp. That means you don't have several worries that often come with MWBCs.

For instance, you do not need to pigtail neutrals because all your outlets (including lamps) are downstream of the split. If you removed the master B/R light and severed the neutral, that would not affect the bathroom et.al.'s neutral.

In the US we have a "belt and suspenders" requirement that both sides be on a single shut-off switch, which turns off both sides together for maintenance. I am being very specific: this is what the rule says. It says nothing about a ganged-trip circuit breaker (though that is a convenient way to do it if you use circuit breakers). Fuses are fine. It's not about overcurrent but worker protection. However any competent electrician working in the green box will recognize the MWBC split. I would not lose any sleep over a lack of ganged shut-off, since none of your outlets have both hots.

You absolutely do need to make sure the two "hots" are punched down to separate 120V legs, so the neutral carries only the difference in current. Measure the voltage between them; it must be 240V. If it is 0 volts, that would mean the neutral would carry the total of both currents in both circuits, which could overload it by 100%.

If I were you, I'd continue the MWBC in service unless you feel a burning need to install AFCI breakers (this being the only reason I don't use MWBCs). If you need GFCI, use a receptacle and put it downstream of the split somewhere. A plain GFCI receptacle works fine as long as it's downstream of the final split, which all your outlets are.

  • Thanks Harper. As you can see in the diagram, there are two basement outlets which are on separate circuits. I was thinking of putting a GFCI receptacle in each and connecting my new runs to them. That way the circuits run in the opposite direction and end at the box with the light. And I would only have the one hot and neutral in that box not used. I thought I might figure out something later to hook up to them, but cap off temporarily until I figure out what to put there. Don't want to leave it there live. Thanks again. – RWHobbs Jan 16 '17 at 20:17
1

That type wiring is allowed in some locations but not where I live. It is okay if the circuits sharing the 14-3 are from each side of the input buss. In theory, the amperage draw on each circuit cancels the amperage draw on the shared neutral. 10 amps on the left circuit, 8 amps on the right circuit, equals 2 amps on the neutral. It saves the electrician a couple bucks but shows just who he is. He would not do wiring for me.

  • The 3 wire run is only about 20' so it wouldn't have cost much more to run 2 14/2 wires up there. It was a co-op that built all the houses on my street about 45 yrs ago. – RWHobbs Jan 16 '17 at 20:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.