I'm over at my grandparents house and they have 2 large protruding cracks in what I guess is butt between two drywall pieces. I scraped the crack a bit with a paint scraper and to my surprise pieces of 'plaster' came off and behind it is what seems to be drywall but no tape and no butt.

They said there might have been wallpaper painted over, however that does not seem to be the case as I didn't 'see' any wallpaper in my scraping.

So to continue with the fix I widened the cracks to the point where none of the 'plaster' was falling off. In one location it was slightly less than the width of a piece of drywall tape, and in the other it was slightly more at one part.

I filled the cracks thus far with joint compound with a slight feather, and will most likely sand this so its entirely flat after it finishes drying so what we are left with is a filled crack area with no protrusions. Then I will most likely apply another coat of joint compound this time feathering it out wider so that it is not noticeable.

My question is, after I sand the first and currently drying coat, should I apply tape or mesh (normally I would do this if it were a small no protruding crack and I didn't have to widen it, or if there was a butt)? There is no seam in the drywall behind it, and I think with adequate feather I can hide the crack seams. I suppose if I did have to mesh or tape it on one I would have to use two pieces of mesh side by side to cover the entirety of the area.

1 Answer 1


Mesh and paper tape are really all about adding strength, which is especially important at seams or wherever the paper bonding surface of the underlying drywall may have torn or weakened.

In this case, if you're sure the underlying drywall is sound, then it means that the entire area of repair will be strong and supported from behind. So, joint compound should get the job done and stay strong. I'd suggest using setting type compound (sometimes referred to as "hot mud") for your first layer since it sets up harder and stronger than the drying type topping compound.

  • That's what I suppose as well. Any idea why the drywall had a thin layer of plaster over it? In both locations this was the case. Since the house was built in the late 80s I suppose maybe the drywalling techniques or the drywall itself wasn't that great so they compensated by applying more compound to help 'flatten' it out.
    – Alex
    Commented Dec 17, 2016 at 7:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.