0

we know that CFL are more sensetive to low tempweratures but what is the reason behind it?And how is it not so in the use of LEDs?

3
  • Related: diy.stackexchange.com/questions/2523/…
    – Niall C.
    Dec 7, 2016 at 16:37
  • @NiallC. I'd actually call it a dupilcate, with the exception that fluorescent lamps don't contain mercury anymore (at least in the US). I "think" typically the gas now is argon or xenon, same principle tho.
    – Tyson
    Dec 7, 2016 at 17:24
  • 1
    Even green tipped florescent lamps do contain very small amounts of mercury link to a standard T8 1.7 Mg of mercury. The content is less than in years past but it is still there. non green tipped 5mg link here for this model. both are avaiable today at just about any store. My understanding was the green tips were ok to dispose of but the non green tip required hazardous waste disposal we reclaim both for safety.
    – Ed Beal
    Dec 7, 2016 at 17:31

2 Answers 2

3

It's the way they work.

LEDs are entirely solid-state and DC. Apply power, zing, light comes out. LEDs don't care about temperature (though the AC/DC converter behind them, might.) The LED lights as fast as the power supply/driver can self-test, sync with its dimmer, and come up. That varies by power supply. For a 12V battery feeding a light strip, it is instantaneous.


Fluorescents are a type of arc-discharge lighting (like neon, metal halide, mercury vapor, high and low pressure sodium, etc). They have a long pressurized tube full of magic gas, and they "strike an arc" down the length of the tube, which ionizes the magic gas and makes it emit light. The gas is not a particularly good conductor of electricity, so getting that arc started is tricky. And this process is rather sensitive to temperature, operating frequency, and the sophistication (i.e. cost) of the ballast.

An instant-start fluorescent blasts an extra-high voltage to try to force a start, but this accelerates bulb wear. To remedy this, a rapid-start fluorescent (ballast) adds an intentional, fixed delay while it heats up small "filaments" in the end of each bulb. A programmed-start ballast detects when the bulb has warmed enough to strike - but that can be 3-4 seconds in extreme cold!

Electronic ballasts are also able to operate at the ideal frequency for fluorescent bulbs - unlike old ballasts which are chained to the far-too-slow 50Hz or 60Hz power (visible to some, and to everyone when the lamp is struggling due to cold.)

Any discharge lighting will struggle in the cold. However, the "high intensity discharge" family (metal halide, mercury vapor, sodium lights) operate VERY hot, so ambient temperature quickly becomes irrelevant.

1
  • 1
    Just a note: While LEDs are not affected by low temperature, high temperatures can cause problems. Contrary to what many seem to believe, LEDs do generate waste heat which needs to be removed. Excess heat can cause thermal runaway (the LED pulling more current than it can sustain, which heats it further, and so on), which will enventually destroy the LED. This is why many LED replacement bulbs are not rated for enclosed fixtures. Dec 7, 2016 at 23:20
1

Most of this is from a quick Google search, but I'm paraphrasing it a little. CFLs use argon gas and a small amount of mercury vapor. The electricity excites that gas, creates an invisible UV light, which interacts with a fluorescent coating on the inside of the bulb, which generates the actual visible light. I believe that the effect caused by colder temperatures is that it slows down the whole reaction. Takes longer to generate the UV light and for that to affect the fluorescent coating inside the light.

I recently bought some flood lights for the house that were super cheap, barely noticing that there was a CFL bulb inside the frosted lens. Takes quite a bit of time to warm up outside up here in Buffalo... Even in the fall when it was 60 or 70F outside it took a good minute to get even close to full brightness. Now it's probably 2 or 3 minutes. At least when they get warmed up they are VERY bright... I just need to get a smart switch or something to fire them up before I leave work. This shorter day stuff during the winter means that it's nearly pitch black outside when I get home at 5:15-5:30PM.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.