I wanted to buy a super efficient multi-stage or atleast 2 stage heat pump and got three quotes but then another contractor came in and refused to quote or install that, saying upstairs master would never get cool enough, and I needed single-stage (american standard silver 16 he recommended). It's a brick 1948 colonial with recent insulation but poor duct work. Someone asked this or very similar 7 months ago-- the comments were useful but varied and I wonder if anyone one has any other thoughts - is there a test that can be done to see? Currently have a 35 yr old furnace and 25 year old air conditioner and upstairs master is marginal in summer- I try shutting vents off downstairs sometimes and that helps.

  • Did a contractor perform a manual-j calculation? This determines the BTUS needed to effectively heat and cool an area. Additionally, don't instantly assume a higher SEER is worth the investment. You will pay more for a higher SEER, but if you don't recoup those savings over the lifetime of the unit it isn't worth it. Look for websites that give an example of SEER savings calculations. – Ramrod Dec 2 '16 at 22:35
  • Do you have zoning? Or why did you think you need multi-stage? – Tyson Dec 2 '16 at 23:59
  • Multi-stage should have zero impact on total capacity. – SomeoneSomewhereSupportsMonica Dec 3 '16 at 1:38

There really is no cure for inadequate duct work that involves making use of the existing ducts. If one looks at the fine print of super efficient systems, there is always a qualification that the units must be installed correctly to achieve the rated performance. Good duct work is a big part of correct installation. If the duct work is marginally bad, adding an inline booster fan to push more airflow where it is needed might work, but that kind of solution reduces both efficiency and reliability.

Ductless mini-splits are sometimes a good option where existing ducts are not usable. Some mini-splits offer the highest efficiencies available and they also are equipped with inverters that provide variable capacity control that adjusts on the fly. Also, different models of the indoor portion of mini-splits are available to satisfy different situations.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.