Does double brick chimney need liner for vented gas logs?

Question

We have a 100-year-old house with a double brick chimney, meaning there's an inner and an outer brick wall. The inner wall is reportedly in not-great, somewhat deteriorated shape. There is no clay or other lining, just a brick and mortar inner layer.

I'm wondering, could it ever be safe to use a chimney like this? It's my understanding that most of the flammable deposits that burning wood creates won't be present when using vented gas logs.

I have received three conflicting opinions by professionals, each possibly with a profit motive to be less than honest. One of the companies insisted that it would be unsafe to use the chimney without adding a modern liner, but based on evidence, they seemed to be the least trustworthy.

Answer 1

If you have a fire in that fireplace, you really need the chimney relined. Its not that it will be any deposits, that is true, but there will still be a possibility of carbon monoxide leaking into the home, if not other fumes.

There are companies that will clean the interior, place a long balloon inside, inflate it and pour a product around it to seal the brick.

Another way to do it is to have a semi-rigid stainless steel pipe set in place. I have only seen this done with furnaces, not fireplaces, but there may be a way nowadays to tie it into the smoke chamber, after it has been restored.