I'm installing painted MDF crown molding, and I wasnt sure which method for covering nail holes is technically correct. Is using caulk considered a shortcut? Or is filling in the holes with wood putty and then painting only for the super perfectionist with too much time on their hands? I already filled in some of the holes with caulk, and I can't really see them when standing on the floor. My only concern is that it will reflect light differently since the paint is semi-gloss.
The key criteria for me is the size of the holes. If you used brads, then I have no problem with using caulk, especially on baseboards. The only possible downside is if you leave a fingerprint in it. You have to have eagle eyes to pick out a small hole like that.
With crown molding though, I'd plan on a lightweight spackle. Mostly because of the cost and effort you already put in installing it, might as well finish it nicely. Vinyl spackle works great, but again if the holes are small, just about anything made by DAP works fine. If you find yourself with a large hole, bondo (auto filler) does amazing things. Or you can use painter's putty, glazing, just about anything can be made to look really good. Sand and touch-up as needed.
Alexa dap caulk in a squeeze tube! It's sandable, printable And super easy to work with. The squeeze tube gives a lot more control as opposed to a caulking gun.