Skip to main content
added 4 characters in body
Source Link
Nikita R.
  • 627
  • 3
  • 13
  • 25

I have two lamps wired to a 3-way regular switch: one in a hallway and another one on the staircase following it. I would like to change the regular switch with motion detection occupancy one, but there's a problem. One of the 3-way switches is in the hallway, but the other one is in the living room (adjacent to the staircase). Which means that if I change the switch to an occupancy one, it will trigger when people are just moving in the living room, not necessarily going to the staircase.

I can see a couple of solutions, but they are too time consuming/expensive:

  1. Move the living room staircase switch to the staircase. But I would like to avoid doing it because it's too much work.
  2. Remove the regular switches completely and buy occupancy sensors that are installed directly on the lamps. It's a better solution than (1), but such sensors could be difficult to match to the existing lamps.

I'm wondering if there's a solution that would be something like this:

  • Replace the hallway switch with 3-way occupancy one
  • Install another 3-way occupancy sensor on/near the staircase lamp
  • Keep or remove the living room switch currently used to control the staircase lamp

I have two lamps wired to a 3-way regular switch: one in a hallway and another one on the staircase following it. I would like to change the regular switch with motion detection occupancy one, but there's a problem. One of the 3-way switches is in the hallway, but the other one is in the living room (adjacent to the staircase). Which means that if I change the switch to an occupancy one, it will trigger when people are just moving in the living room, not necessarily going to the staircase.

I can see a couple of solutions, but they are too time consuming/expensive:

  1. Move the living room staircase switch to the staircase. But I would like to avoid doing it because it's too much work.
  2. Remove the regular switches completely and buy occupancy sensors that are installed directly on the lamps. It's a better solution than (1), but such sensors could be difficult to match to the existing lamps.

I'm wondering if there's a solution that would be something like this:

  • Replace the hallway switch with 3-way occupancy one
  • Install another 3-way occupancy sensor on/near the staircase lamp
  • Keep or remove the living room switch currently used to control the staircase lamp

I have two lamps wired to a 3-way regular switch: one in a hallway and another one on the staircase following it. I would like to change the regular switch with motion detection occupancy one, but there's a problem. One of the 3-way switches is in the hallway, but the other one is in the living room (adjacent to the staircase). Which means that if I change the switch to an occupancy one, it will trigger when people are just moving in the living room, not necessarily going to the staircase.

I can see a couple of solutions, but they are too time consuming/expensive:

  1. Move the living room staircase switch to the staircase. But I would like to avoid doing it because it's too much work.
  2. Remove the regular switches completely and buy occupancy sensors that are installed directly on the lamps. It's a better solution than (1), but such sensors could be difficult to match to the existing lamps.

I'm wondering if there's a solution that would be something like this:

  • Replace the hallway switch with 3-way occupancy one
  • Install another 3-way occupancy sensor on/near the staircase lamp
  • Keep or remove the living room switch currently used to control the staircase lamp
Source Link
Nikita R.
  • 627
  • 3
  • 13
  • 25

Is there a 3-way occupancy switch with one sensor being external?

I have two lamps wired to a 3-way regular switch: one in a hallway and another one on the staircase following it. I would like to change the regular switch with motion detection occupancy one, but there's a problem. One of the 3-way switches is in the hallway, but the other one is in the living room (adjacent to the staircase). Which means that if I change the switch to an occupancy one, it will trigger when people are just moving in the living room, not necessarily going to the staircase.

I can see a couple of solutions, but they are too time consuming/expensive:

  1. Move the living room staircase switch to the staircase. But I would like to avoid doing it because it's too much work.
  2. Remove the regular switches completely and buy occupancy sensors that are installed directly on the lamps. It's a better solution than (1), but such sensors could be difficult to match to the existing lamps.

I'm wondering if there's a solution that would be something like this:

  • Replace the hallway switch with 3-way occupancy one
  • Install another 3-way occupancy sensor on/near the staircase lamp
  • Keep or remove the living room switch currently used to control the staircase lamp