Do you use ac in the summer? IfIf this is about comfort then there are options. If you expect to re-coup your material money packback will likely be 10+ years.
I'd probably use intello-wrap and roxul batt insulation. maybe unfaced xpsstart with great stuff spray foamadding roxul to seal jointsthe joists bays and then roxul foruse intello stapled to the flash and batt approachunderside of the joists.
is ownership The intello will allow moisture to pass through, hold the insulation in place and provide a strata type arrangement with this as common area or are you renting? youwind break. You could try it just on one area of floor and see how much better it seems before using the intellosolution across the board. Tape the perimeter of the intelligent wrb with acoustic seal that wouldsomething cheap like tuck tape. That should cut the wind cooling factor down considerably and be pretty cheap / easy.