This is pretty strange: a few months ago I moved into a new apartment with a Fisher & Paykel refrigerator (freezer on top). It's a fairly basic unit, and until today it worked OK. This morning I opened the fridge door and the light did not come on; I figured the bulb had burned out. But then I opened the freezer door, and the fridge light turned on! There has never been any light in the freezer compartment as far as I remember, so this role reversal is quite troubling.

I did some poking around and discovered a magnetic sensor near the top of the fridge door. But it happens to be equidistant to the bottom of the freezer door! This is quite a strange design--you can see it on the second page of this PDF (which covers a different issue with the same type of fridge): http://www.accentis.com.au/downloads/misc/How%20I%20fixed%20my%20Fisher%20and%20Paykel%20Fridge%20Active%20Smart%20Fridge.pdf

With the small white plastic cover removed from the face between the doors, a cylindrical black magnetic reed switch is accessible. I pulled it out--it has about two inches of extra wiring, and played around with it. I tried turning it about its main axis to see if its orientation matters--that didn't change much.

It simply seems that the sensor is far too sensitive, and that the freezer door seal is more than enough to trip it, even as the door is still 1-2 inches from fully closed. It is hard to believe how this system ever worked.

Calling a repairman is likely to be expensive and the landlord will probably try to make me pay for it (I live outside the US, so don't be too surprised). Entirely disabling the switch seems improper, not only because the light would stay on but because this fridge seems to change its fan behavior depending on the door open/close state. I briefly experimented with taping the sensor to a location much lower on the face of the unit, far enough from the freezer door to avoid it tripping when only the freezer is closed. But it's hard to get the fridge door to trip the sensor this way--the light seems to just stay on, as if the sensor were designed to do the opposite job it is meant to do.

This is pretty strange: a few months ago I moved into a new apartment with a Fisher & Paykel refrigerator (freezer on top). It's a fairly basic unit, and until today it worked OK. This morning I opened the fridge door and the light did not come on; I figured the bulb had burned out. But then I opened the freezer door, and the fridge light turned on! There has never been any light in the freezer compartment as far as I remember, so this role reversal is quite troubling.

I did some poking around and discovered a magnetic sensor near the top of the fridge door. But it happens to be equidistant to the bottom of the freezer door! This is quite a strange design

From the second page of this PDF

With the small white plastic cover removed from the face between the doors, a cylindrical black magnetic reed switch is accessible. I pulled it out--it has about two inches of extra wiring, and played around with it. I tried turning it about its main axis to see if its orientation matters--that didn't change much.

It simply seems that the sensor is far too sensitive, and that the freezer door seal is more than enough to trip it, even as the door is still 1-2 inches from fully closed. It is hard to believe how this system ever worked.

Calling a repairman is likely to be expensive and the landlord will probably try to make me pay for it (I live outside the US, so don't be too surprised). Entirely disabling the switch seems improper, not only because the light would stay on but because this fridge seems to change its fan behavior depending on the door open/close state. I briefly experimented with taping the sensor to a location much lower on the face of the unit, far enough from the freezer door to avoid it tripping when only the freezer is closed. But it's hard to get the fridge door to trip the sensor this way--the light seems to just stay on, as if the sensor were designed to do the opposite job it is meant to do.