I need some help here. We recently primed and painted an exterior wood door. The second coat of latex paint was still semi-wet and I accidentally touched an area of the door with my fingertips which left some unsightly dips. We tried painting over that area again but it looks a bit rough. Here's a pic

We'd like to put in the door tomorrow but I'm not sure how to fix this quickly. Right now the area is "sticky" so it's too wet to sand down and too dry to smoothly re-paint over. Any advice for how to recover here?
Just thinking out loud... could we scrape the goopy area?