Take the 2-minute tour ×
Home Improvement Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for contractors and serious DIYers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Our A/C evaporator coil freeze up last year, so I called out a technician.
He said that it was charged with the proper amount of Freon, and my problem [paraphrased] "something had narrowed the inside of the coil", and said that "cleaning the coil would be a waste of money since that would cost ~$900 (uncharge, take out, clean, reinstall, recharge), and a new A/C is only $1800".

My BS alarm was going off at the time and I'm going to get a second opinion, but in the mean time:

Q1: Can a coil go bad in the manner he described?

Q2: I know in the system there should be only Freon and lubricating oil, but can you figure out if there's any contaminates ?

share|improve this question
Do some research to find out if the coil is under warranty. If it is, it will make your question mute. You'll just have to pay to have the new one installed. It would cost < $1000 –  Edwin Mar 22 '14 at 19:29

1 Answer 1

Q1: The coil can get plugged with contaminants. Maybe if it was improperly filled, or water got in through a leak. Both situations tend to be rare.

Q2: I'm sure diagnostic equipment exists, but most techs would either just flush it or pull new copper line.

Some other things that tend to cause frozen coils:

  1. Restricted airflow due to a dirty or plugged air filter. Make sure the filter is clean. Also, maybe try a basic pleated one that has good air flow, versus an expensive dense allergy type filter that slows the air down quite a bit.

  2. High humidity indoors. If it's humid indoors, don't set the thermostat too low to start with. If it's set low, like 65f, and the house temp is 85f and humid to start with, it'll run continuously pulling warm humid air over the cold coils. That can lead to freezing. In that scenario, set the thermostat to 78f, wait till it stabilizes at that temp for a few hours, then lower it a bit more. See if the freezing returns or not.

  3. Low airflow due to narrow ducting or blower issues. You'd need a tech to check this out.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.