Home Improvement Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for contractors and serious DIYers. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I have two new Carrier Infinity CNPVP high efficiency direct-vent furnaces in my basement for my 3500 sf house. The air intakes for both units are not plumbed outside but instead are drawing air from right above the unit. Apparently there were issues getting access to an outside wall. My questions are:

  1. Is this venting OK?
  2. Will it hurt my efficiency?
  3. If I do have to vent it outside can I use flexible pipe or can I gang both furnaces into a single input pipe?
share|improve this question

Many direct vent heaters use a through the wall concentric pipe system where the cool intake air comes in through the larger outter diameter and the hot exhaust leaves via the smaller inner diameter of the two pipes. This allows there to be a compact and safe transition through the wall so that the hot pipe does not represent a fire hazard to the surrounding wall materials.

You should look closely at your installation to make sure that the exhaust exits are piped and vented in a safe manner without risk of high heat leading to fire danger. As you describe your installation the concentric cooling scheme is not being applied.

share|improve this answer
High efficiency PVC or CPVC venting materials and a zero clearance to combustibles. The exhaust gas of the furnace will not reach over 140 degrees Fahrenheit. The concentric vent kits are normally used on fireplaces or other mid to standard efficiency Direct-Vent appliances – Mnc123 Jan 4 '14 at 6:46

1) it is not ideal but it is safe. There are 2 potential problems with it: decreased efficiency and non-uniform pressure in the house (your basement will be pulling air from the rest of the house which may result in the doors being slammed, drafts, etc. The effects are usually minor)

2) it will decrease your efficiency by probably 3-5%

3) Most use a regular 2" PVC. It is relatively cheap and easy to work with. I am not sure what the code says about ganging them into single input, so I would ask a qualified HVAC person on this one but I don't see anything obviously wrong with it.

share|improve this answer

The main reason this is done is to save installation costs for the installer, along with saving the materials needed to pipe the intakes to the outside. All venting systems must be installed according to local gas codes and manufacturers installation instructions.

There is no real concerns with having the intake air being drawn from the inside of the structure.... in most cases. As long as your house does not severely go into negative pressure you will be fine. This will depend on how tightly your home is constructed. Most new homes do not come with the intake piped to the outside either. I have worked for many many large home builders, and when you are putting up 1000 homes, all they care about is saving the $100 dollars on each house.

The issues with having the intake air being taken from inside the envelope of the structure is that normally the intakes will suck up a lot of dust from the basement. Most people do not clean around the furnaces so that is usually the main cause, however if the area around the furnace, and the unit itself is cleaned regularly or yearly this will not really be an issue. The other issue with having this is when homeowners finish there basements. If a room is build around the furnace, you need to install 2 grills to supply fresh air to the room. In cases where this is not done, the furnace will starve for air and either shut down as a safety, or start running very inefficiently.

Those are the only real concerns with having the unit being piped inside of the house. I however still always recommend to have it done, and usually install it on every furnace installation i do, unless something is agreed upon with the homeowner. The main reason i do this is to not have to worry about homes going into negative pressure, and the fact that i can not control how people will be finishing there basements if they do in the future. Having the intake piped outside wont give you a noticeable increase in efficiency or energy savings by any means.

Now there are some minor draw backs with having the unit piped outside. When doing so you need to take extra time to make sure the intake is installed with proper clearances (whether it be to the outlet of the exhaust, or to the vent of the gas meter). The other thing you have to be aware of is that intake pipes, as well as exhaust pipes being blocked is a common thing. I have found literally everything imaginable inside of venting systems, and it is not a easy task to remove the blockage in most cases. Putting a piece 1/2" chicken wire will help to keep things from finding its way inside. Usually the cause is the homeowners children dropping rocks or balls into the vent. The other cause for a blocked vent may be animals, or an excessively high snow level. I do not recommend putting a tightly woven mesh, or any mesh that has holes less thats 3/8" in size. Doing so may cause a restriction in the intake pipe causing the furnace to shut down inadequate air supply. For the exhaust i would not use any mesh that had less that 1/2" holes. If a tightly woven mesh is used it will become saturated with water and then freeze when the furnace is on its off cycle. This would cause the furnace to shut down and lock out due to blockage in the venting.

share|improve this answer

stay with a 80 % furnace when proper venting not available. this sounds illegal and unethical contracting . I have cat litter boxes in basement so clay dust would be sucked into the combustion chamber burning out the furnace prematurely. home owners should be warned about these sleazy hillbilly contractors. a house for sale I was looking at has the furnace set up this way . a realtor could not explain why . I did not buy the house

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.